go to mobile version »

Most Commented

Crosscut articles of the past 10 days with the most reader comments.

ALL COMMENTS »

Health / Medicine »

 

MYDOC productions

A scene from 'Unlisted'

 

'How I wonder how they are'

A Seattle MD makes a courageous documentary, showing at STIFF this week, about her father's estrangement from his family, owing to schizophrenia, and its toll on the families.

This week the Seattle True International Film Festival (STIFF) will feature local physician Delaney Ruston’s Unlisted: A Story of Schizophrenia, a film about her father, who was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia shortly after she was born. At the time, Richard Ruston was a graduate student in English at Berkeley. During his wife’s pregnancy the couple was evicted from apartments five times because among other things he’d climb telephone poles and scream at people from his perch. Her parents divorced when Delaney was a baby.

Still, this father adored his daughter and tried to stay in touch with her. Richard’s parents told her that he depended on her presence in his life to give him a sense of stability, but Delaney never knew whether he’d quietly play chess with her during one of her visits or pace around his apartment fuming that CIA agents were spying on him. Sometimes he’d show up at her school and yell her name through the fence, humiliating her and scaring her classmates, until the principal emerged to quiet him down.

Years later when Delaney was a medical student he’d cruise the Stanford campus frantically asking for her. By then she was old enough to seek help for her father, but a stunted mental health system frustrated every attempt to do more than witness his disintegration. After graduating from medical school Delaney unlisted her phone number and moved to Seattle without telling her father her new address, hoping that occasional visits to him in L.A. would keep him from coming north to look for her.

Yet he was on her mind as she tended her patients at Pike Market Medical Clinic, many with mental illnesses, many suffering in isolation because the sufferers were disconnected from their families. And when her young son started asking questions about the grandfather he’d never met, she wondered whether hiding from her father’s pain had been a good idea. Unlisted documents her efforts at reviving her relationship with her dad after ten years of considerable distance.

In the film Richard is a charming, funny, convivial man in his 60s, doing well on a new regimen of medications because five years ago, after four years on a waiting list, he finally was able to move into a housing complex with on-site support services for people with mental illnesses. He was a handsome man in his youth, with a face in the film that would closely resemble Norman Mailer’s at 80 if Mailer’s dentist had specialized in extractions and tooth darkening. There’s a framed portrait of a smiling George W. Bush in Richard’s apartment even though he’d been a lifelong Democrat, which he cheerfully explains to his daughter: “I became a Republican after Al Gore hired the wrong lawyers in Florida.”

This is a man who might start reciting a Shakespeare sonnet at the mention of love, though with a wink at Delaney he’ll smuggle “concubines” into “Let me not to the marriage of true minds” because it happens to rhyme. A stroll on the Santa Monica Pier with his daughter prompts him to mangle the start of Arnold’s “Dover Beach” with his special verbal torques. Passages from an unpublished novel that he wrote over the course of many years, quoted in voice-over, move with the kaleidoscopic elisions of the schizophrenic mind into arresting moments, as when something “vanishes as silently as the insects of the night.” A master at chess, Richard gently kvetches and twinkles at his daughter’s inept plays on the board.

Yet this is a man who wasn’t invited to his daughter’s graduations from high school, from Cornell, or from Stanford Medical School, and he wasn’t invited to her wedding. As he reminds Delaney of this series of rebuffs, one by one, with the camera alternating between close-ups of the father’s frustrated sorrow and of the daughter’s cool steady gaze, he musters a crooked grin to make light of his losses. “What,” he laughs finally, “does an invitation look like?” In such scenes our sympathies almost always lie with the father, even though we know that his harrowing disruptions of his daughter’s life are part of what turned her into a wary, guarded woman — “thick-skinned,” as she describes herself.

The story centers on Delaney’s hesitant but stubborn weaving, through undefended encounters with her father, various relatives, and her own heart, of a bond with her father that could endure. Making the documentary took enormous courage on her part. She’s making a plea for better understanding of mental illness and improved public policy, but she’s not oblivious to the fact that through most of the film she comes across as walled off and remote. Her way of connecting with her father is to act as his doctor. Yet in several very touching moments it’s he who makes sense of her, not the other way around.

1 | 2 next page

Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism by becoming a member of Crosscut.com today!


Comments:

Posted Wed, Jun 10, 12:59 p.m. inappropriate

As someone who grew exhausted and was eventually physically endangered by a loved one with mental illness, I am compelled to say that the daughter did the right thing by avoiding contact with her unfortunate father. Living around someone so afflicted is a life of walking on eggshells, and in the end, the only way out of the chaos is to leave. This might sound cruel, dispassionate, or not dutiful to many, but a life with someone like this is exhausting and takes a huge toll on one's health and peace of mind. The decision to leave is very painful, but in the end, each of us is responsible for watching out for our own health and well-being first.

Posted Sun, Jun 14, 2:35 p.m. inappropriate

This is a moving story--I will try to see the film when it is shown on Wednesday. I recognize the mental illness symptoms of the father as much as I can also feel the emotional confict the daughter has in avoiding him. As the writer above said: being around someone like this is exhausting. Although treatment helps a bit, it doesn't do nearly enough to return the person to anything like normal functioning.

Posted Fri, Jul 3, 5:52 p.m. inappropriate

This is, indeed, a moving testimony to the tenacity of the illness and the struggles that occur for the individual and those around them. Children seldom have the internal or external resources to cope with the chaos that periods of decompensation produce and it is essential that there be adults around for their protection and mentoring. As we age and get a more experienced perspective, it is easier to manage our responses to familiy members with illness though there is always a part of us that remembers 'the way things were before' and grieves for it periodically. Interestingly enough, when the person with the illness is able to differentiate between their pre and post onset states they often intensely grieve the losses they have experienced. Unfortunately, suicide is not uncommon for people in this situation, and, though they may disagree with the choice, many can understand the reasoning behind the action. KG

Join Crosscut now! Subscribe to Newsletter About Crosscut Advertise Web Feeds