The Senate will probably not prevail over the House and Gov. Gregoire, who oppose the sales tax boost. Majority Leader Lisa Brown is trying to broker a compromise that is not another victory for Speaker Chopp.
Login / Register
go to mobile version »

Our Sponsors:

READ MORE »

Our Members

Many thanks to

Margaret Buckwitz

and

CD Stimson Company

some of our many supporters.

ALL MEMBERS »

Washington Legislature »

 

Showdown on the sales tax

 

The Senate will probably not prevail over the House and Gov. Gregoire, who oppose the sales tax boost. Majority Leader Lisa Brown is trying to broker a compromise that is not another victory for Speaker Chopp.

Lisa Brown.

Washington Senate Majority Leader Lisa Brown, D-Spokane.

Topics: Politics

Today marks the start of week three of a legislative special session that, when Gov. Chris Gregoire declared it, was only supposed to last seven days. Each day that passes, Gregoire ratchets up her rhetoric. She’s moved from simply frustrated to now “disgusted” that lawmakers have yet to resolve their differences.

Majority Democrats in the House and Senate are locked in a stare-down over whether to hike the sales tax. The Senate says yes, the House and Gregoire say no. But the governor refuses to flash her veto pen.

Both chambers are so dug in that lawmakers have been sent home to resume their normal lives. Left behind to negotiate are Speaker of the House Frank Chopp and Senate Majority Leader Lisa Brown. On Friday, reporters staking out the third floor of the Capitol witnessed Chopp and his chief of staff cross the rotunda to meet with Brown.

Half an hour later, Chopp emerged with little more to say than he still opposes the sales tax. Brown then invited reporters into her office and offered the first hint that the Senate may blink first. She said she’s begun looking for $200 million in taxes that could replace the Senate’s proposed two-tenths-of-a-penny sales tax increase. What those alternative revenue sources might be, Brown isn’t yet saying.

But it’s the first sign of a possible break in the sales tax stand-off. It would be easy to conclude the Senate is about to get rolled yet again by Frank Chopp. Brown admits that in the final hours of last year’s session, she feels the House reneged on deals that had been struck between the two chambers.

No doubt about it, Brown is outnumbered by Chopp and Gregoire on the sales tax. But the special session clock runs 30 days. So why tip her hand now? Consider what Brown does when she isn’t leading Senate Democrats. She teaches organizational leadership at Gonzaga University in Spokane. In other words, she knows a leadership vacuum when she sees one.

Gregoire claims she’s been bringing good-faith compromise ideas to the legislature to no avail. In reality, the governor has spent the past two weeks colluding with the House to kill the sales tax. In the House, Majority Leader Lynn Kessler supports a small temporary sales tax increase. But she hasn’t been willing to go around Chopp and mount a campaign for it in the caucus.

That leaves Brown with the opportunity — and perhaps ultimately the obligation — to lead the way to a true compromise.

In the end, Senate Democrats will very likely have to give up on the sales tax. But that doesn’t mean they have to accept the House and governor’s emphasis on business taxes, which gives moderate and conservative state senators heartburn.

In the coming days, Brown’s challenge will be to divine a true “third way” — one that allows her members to sacrifice the sales tax to the altar of compromise without feeling like they got routed by Frank Chopp. If Brown can pull this off, she’ll emerge as the MVP of the special session.

Austin Jenkins is the Olympia-based political reporter for Northwest News Network, a consortium of public radio stations in Washington, Oregon, and Idaho. He is host of "Inside Olympia" on TVW, and he blogs at WALedge.com. You can e-mail him at ajenkins@kuow.com.


Topics: Politics

Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism by becoming a member of Crosscut.com today!

Comments:

Posted Mon, Mar 29, 6:57 a.m. Inappropriate

Brown for MVP? "Most Vitriolic Partisan" perhaps, but certainly no value being delivered to the taxpayers in Washington.

Posted Mon, Mar 29, 7:02 a.m. Inappropriate

Austin, on a different note, I watched your interview with McKenna and Kriedler this weekend. I was very disappointed in Mr. Kriedler's inability to articulate how HCR was actually going save Washingtonians any money or bring additional insurance companies into the State to compete. What was your take?

Posted Mon, Mar 29, 9:05 a.m. Inappropriate

Ms. Brown seems a little too enthusiastic about taxes at times but at least she is willing to seek revenue in a broad based highly visible tax. The alternatives that Chopp and the Governor advocate are taxes that are largely hidden from voters, perceivable only in slight added costs for goods and services (which voters will cheerfully blame on the businesses involved). I think Brown gets the "honest politician" medallion here.

Posted Tue, Mar 30, 1:22 p.m. Inappropriate

Kieth,
Another way to phrase your point is that the House's approach is to avoid any across-the-board tax increase and to target taxes at avoidable "sins" such as candy and bottled water and at non-performing tax breaks, such as a break on taxing first mortgages given to WaMu before it was taken over by an out-of-state bank (community banks are exempt).

This session has been a breakthrough in legislators actually evaluating corporate tax beaks as expenditures that should be weighed against other possible expenditures, such as education or Basic Health. How can giving $67 million to Citibank, Chase and Washovia possibly be better than providing education and health care to our kids?

Your accusations of "hiding" taxes and "dishonesty" are unmerited. Washington State Democrats voted in January against raising the sales tax, since we are already the 50th most regressive state in terms of state and local taxes. Sen. Brown isn't listening to her grassroots.
--Sarajane Siegfriedt

Posted Mon, Apr 5, 10:05 p.m. Inappropriate

Washington Research Council analysis shows the House budget will INCREASE state spending by $322 million while the Senate proposes to increase it a more moderate $196 million. Approximately $1 billion in program cuts are offset by increased spending in other programs.

There is no justification for tax increases of any type, transparency or timing until there is demonstrated fiscal responsibility on the spending side.

Join Crosscut now!
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow Us »