Hideous Belltown
The McGuire Apartments, sheathed in scaffolding
Summer thrives as a testament to the can-do spirit of the people of Seattle. For the first time in 90 years (except for an understandable hiatus during World War II), we were about to face a summer without a July 4 public fireworks display. There was no one to pay for it in these tough times. In stepped KIRO talk-radio host Dave Ross and restaurateur Tom Douglas, who began raising money on the air. The funds were quickly generated by individuals and the business community, including $125,000 checks from Starbucks and Microsoft.
Shortly thereafter, it was reported that the annual Seafair hydroplane race was at risk of cancellation because it didn’t have funding either. So, just as people had hustled to ensure a summer with skyrockets, a new hero was needed to save us from the first season in 60 years without thunder boats on Lake Washington. Blessedly, Duke Moscrip, owner of Duke’s Chowder House, came up with the needed $40,000 so the race could go on. It’s nice to know that Wall Street isn’t the only thing that can get a bailout.
Our summer rituals may seem frivolous, but they're part of who we are and how we celebrate our few dry (well, sometimes) weeks each year. An added benefit is that the carbon footprint of Seafair will ensure even warmer summers ahead, for the whole planet.
Those are examples of Seattle’s can-do spirit. Now here’s the can’t-do part. While Seattle was saving summer fun, the city declared a 25-story building in Belltown, the McGuire Apartments, to be unsafe. So unsafe, in fact, that it is slated to be torn down. The building is only 9 years old. Since when did Seattle high-rises come with the life expectancy of a bottle rocket?
The problem appears to be that steel support cables holding up the building’s floors weren’t properly installed, and a bad job of applying grout exposed them to corrosion. The result is a structure at risk of turning into the worst kind of pancake house. Adding to the embarrassment of this faulty tower: One of its owners is the Carpenters Union.
If union carpenters can't build a safe building, just where does high-rise Seattle stand, or fall? Mayor Mike McGinn has ordered the city to inspect its own records to see if there are any more collapsible buildings out there.
Doubly humiliating is the fact that water is the cause for concern. In this the McGuire is not alone. How many times have you seen new projects go up with time-lapse quickness, and a little later they’re shrink-wrapped in a condo condom because of leaks, mildew, gooey plaster, bad air, or toxic mold?
On the heels of the McGuire debacle came news that Seattle’s brand-new South Shore School was to be closed down for the year because students and staff were suffering itching and nausea. I always felt that way in school but they never closed one for me. But I was allergic to schoolwork, not bad air. The source of the problem was thought to be chemicals produced in part by damp concrete. So not only can't Seattle decide which schools to close, we can't open new ones either.
We invaders have lived in the Pacific Northwest for more than 200 years. This is a place rather well known for rain. Yet despite all of our accumulated centuries of wisdom and all of our technology, we can't, in the 21st century, construct buildings that keep us dry? No wonder they’re talking about putting Chihuly glass in a new building at Seattle Center: They’ll need plenty of bowls to catch the drips.
We're frequently described as a city that can talk any plan to death, a town that's hung up in gridlock. How is it that the mayor has stalled the tunnel replacing the Alaskan Way Viaduct? Why haven't we replaced the 520 bridge, the South Park Bridge, the waterfront seawall?
In light of new developments, I guess we should be glad about these delays. It’s not just a matter of not building things like we used to; perhaps we shouldn’t build anything at all. At least not until we can remember how to do it properly.
This story originally appeared in the July issue of Seattle Magazine.
Comments:
Posted Thu, Aug 5, 4:42 a.m. Inappropriate
Knute, with the deepest respect, this is about as apples-and-rutabagas as you can get! We live in an urban region with over 3 million citizens, only a fraction of which live in Montlake. So when you try to compare can-do spirit of the impromptu funding of a couple of summer events with the can't-do of two unfortunate construction projects (out of hundreds of thousands of successful buildings) ... and then try to end with a suggestion that this has some applicability to the results of 15 years of process-and-evaluation-and-more-process to get a transit-friendly, environmentally sensitive rebuild of a major east-west corridor? Or worse, to suggest that the project should be delayed "until we remember how to do it properly." Uh ... is a case of writer's block to blame for this rather thin piece?
Posted Thu, Aug 5, 8:01 a.m. Inappropriate
The article also reminds us of the old saying that, “a camel is really a horse that was designed by urban hobbyists, blue-ribbon panels, stakeholder committees, evangelical consulting firms, PR flaks, political insiders and weak elected officials.”
Posted Thu, Aug 5, 8:20 a.m. Inappropriate
apples and rutabagas—sounds like something Tom Douglas might be interested in giving a whirl.
Posted Thu, Aug 5, 9:33 a.m. Inappropriate
I honestly expect more from you Knute. This is pretty weak stuff. Horray for fireworks and hydroplanes; Boooo to big complicated projects. There's a recipe for a great society...
Posted Thu, Aug 5, 11:10 a.m. Inappropriate
Knute, the shrink wrapped buildings and especially the McGuire fiasco deserve a lot more attention than they are getting. I believe the McGuire flaws were discovered because of an unusual post occupation inspection which just happened to reveal that the post-tensioning cables were at risk of failure. This should have led to a lot of inspection of post-tensioned concrete slabs in Seattle (and elsewhere). Has it? I dunno. The procedures for post-tensioning concrete have been around for maybe fifty years but I don't think post-tensioning of high-rise slabs has been done that long and the challenges of compliance and inspection are made substantially more difficult than in low rise parking structures and the like. The failure of the exterior walls in countless new (and frequently expensive) buildings is a scandal; it used to be just EIFS cladding but now even metal siding buildings are being torn apart (how do they know they are doing better the second time? or in at least one case I know of, for the third time?)
As far as I am aware other comparable cities, e.g., Portland and Vancouver, do not have this problem at least not at the scale of Seattle. It is a worrisome problem and it deserves your illumination.
Posted Thu, Aug 5, 3:01 p.m. Inappropriate
9 years ago, Seattle was in a rush to transform it's downtown to a more livable place. With emphasis on the Belltown neighborhood. It was also a landlords market then too. Perhaps the McGuire is an example of such haste.
Regardless, I struggle to make the leap from the 4th of July and Hydro's to shoddy construction projects. They seem like mutually exclusive problems. The dilemma Knute is lamenting over doesnt seem exclusive to Seattle. Just look at the World Trade Center, It's been 10 years it's nowhere near the stage of completion the first WTC was in the same amount of time.
I have an easier time relating to our changing traditions, character and regional epistemology that seems to have drifted away from what was generally thought of as distinct. We lost the Sonics..the Great American Food & Beverage Company...The Bubbleator...The Fountain is safe...Bumbershoot costs of fortune to get into (which seems like a major contradiction of it's intended purpose)...there were no condo's on alki...The Bite of Seattle only served 'samples' intead of entres. Gone are the Dancing Rainer Beers (no more dancing clams either :(
I hope Scones & the Puyallup fair arent next
Dont hold bake Knute. let it all out!
Posted Mon, Aug 9, 8:15 p.m. Inappropriate
But master, you ask too much.
Login or register to add your voice to the conversation.