This 'Barber' could be called 'The Bachelor of Seville'

Seattle Opera's hilarious production borrows elements of 'The Bachelor' and 'American Idol' but still showcases the depth of talent here. Just one quibble: a needless colliding-robot scene.

Kate Lindsey as Rosina and David Adam Moore as Figaro.

Kate Lindsey as Rosina and David Adam Moore as Figaro. Rozarii Lynch, courtesy of Seattle Opera

Sarah Coburn played Rosina on opening night, with Lawrence Brownlee as Count Almaviva.

Sarah Coburn played Rosina on opening night, with Lawrence Brownlee as Count Almaviva. Rosarii Lynch, courtesy of Seattle Opera

Conductor Dean Williamson at the fortepiano.

Conductor Dean Williamson at the fortepiano. Bill Mohn

Okay, last week we were fooling around in the lobby with The Barber of McCaw. This week it's time to get serious with a rollicking show that could be called The Bachelor of Seville.

The more-than-suitable suitor is Count Almaviva. The rose? Technically, it doesn't show up until the comic opera Der Rosenkavalier a full century later, where it's pure invention on the part of Richard Strauss. We have to make do, in Gioachino Rossini's hilarious Barber of Seville, with the notion of a romantic serenade.

The commedia dell'arte genre requires a collection of stock figures: a young hero, a beautiful heroine, an old meddler, a dashing soldier, and so on. Youth versus age, servants versus masters, women versus men. Rossini, not yet 24 when Barber premiered, was clearly on the side of the newcomers, the subjugated, the females.

Figaro, well, he's the barber at a time when barbers did a bit of everything, from shaves & haircuts to bloodletting to mailing letters. A Fixer, if you will, or, in the Seattle Opera staging of the piece, a combination reality show host, field producer and location manager.

And lest we forget, there's a hefty element of "American Idol" here as well. Each of the characters is called upon to sing an aria (or two) designed to showcase their best stuff. In the opening night cast (Saturday, Jan. 15), Lawrence Brownlee blew the field away with a dazzling and rarely performed aria at the end of the opera, "Cessa di più resistere" ("Resistance is futile").

The two Rosinas, played opening night by Sarah Coburn and Sunday (Jan. 16) by Kate Lindsey, did their best as well, with dueling versions of "Una Voce Poco Fa", a sort of "Dear Diary" that starts with dreamy thoughts of the man behind the voice that has just serenaded her, then digresses into a headstrong "my guardian's not going to push me around" fantasy.

Every character lives in a fantasy, it turns out. Figaro thinks he's a sought-after bigshot capable of fixing anything; Almaviva thinks he's irresistible (he serenades the audience, not his beloved); the doddering Bartolo thinks he's reasonable and charming; Basilio spins empty-headed evil plans of slander.

Only the housemaid Berta knows the truth: that the cruel march of time is threatening to leave her an old maid. Sally Wolf, who sings this part, has the vocal chops to play leading roles; in fact, she's a semi-retired diva with a long list of starring credits. Far from being wasted in a minor role, she reminds us of what depth Seattle Opera has when it comes to casting its supporting singers.

Dean Williamson does double-duty in the pit, keeping up the frenetic orchestral pace and playing the fortepiano during the recitatives as well. Peter Kazaras had the pleasure of directing many of his former Young Artist Program performers and resisted the temptation to turn Barber into slapstick, with the notable exception of the first-half closer. Seriously, colliding robots? Bachelor — I mean Barber — is plenty funny without another layer of artifice. 

In the end, of course, love conquers all, Rosina graciously acccepts Almaviva's figurative rose, and even the bad guys are accorded a measure of respect. It's an opera without a mean bone in its body — The Barber of Civility, if you will.

If you go: Seattle Opera presents Gioachino Rossini's The Barber of Seville, through Jan. 29 at McCaw Hall, 321 Mercer St., Seattle. Tickets cost $25 to $208; during a Family Day matinee on Jan. 23, up to four $15 student tickets can be purchased with one full-price ticket. Tickets are available by phone (206-389-7676), at the box office (1020 John St., Seattle), or online.

Seattle writer Ronald Holden blogs at Cornichon.org. He can be reached at editor@crosscut.com.


Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism. Become a member of Crosscut today!

Comments:

Posted Tue, Jan 18, 10:21 a.m. Inappropriate


"Seriously, Colliding robots?" Seriously, haven't you ever seen the Marx Brothers' "Duck Soup" or "A Night at the Opera"????!!!!!!

And seriously, that is David Adam Moore, baritone, as the Barber of Seville in the photo w/Kate Lindsey.

Brooknook

Posted Tue, Jan 18, 7:45 p.m. Inappropriate

I was there on opening night too, and while I rarely agree with critics I have to concur that the show was wonderful, but the robot-dance blocking at the end of Act I was so embarassingly bad that I couldn't look. It didn't spoil the entire show...the singing was quite good (Figaro was amazing), acting charming (Rosina...wow!) and the other comic elements were quite funny (Marx bros, etc). I'd argue that part of the comedia del arte tradition is trying on gags, seeing if they fly, then pulling them if they fall flat and trying something else. Given that I'd say their batting percentage was pretty good but they really need to fix the end of Act I...not a small request, but it needs to happen.

MattL

Login or register to add your voice to the conversation.

Join Crosscut now!
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow Us »