Komen cuts to Planned Parenthood hit Northwest
Anti-abortion activism has caused estrangement of two agencies serving women's health needs. Caught in the middle: women in Washington and Idaho served by breast-cancer screenings.
Because a Florida congressman demands an investigation of abortion spending, some 400 women in rural areas of Clallam County in Washington face the loss of breast cancer screening. So do another 400 in the Boise, Idaho, area, but they face a worse dilemma: They’re refugee women from Africa and Asia, relocated to Idaho through the International Rescue Committee, and most lack the language skills to look for mammogram providers and other breast cancer support on their own.
For years, Planned Parenthood of the Great Northwest has used funds from the huge Susan B. Komen for the Cure Foundation to provide cancer screening treatments to women in Clallam County and in the Boise/Twin Falls area, administered by Planned Parenthood’s Puget Sound affiliate in Seattle. But as of this week, under congressional pressure over Planned Parenthood’s abortion assistance, the Komen Foundation has ended its contributions to Planned Parenthood’s breast cancer screening programs. Nineteen of Planned Parenthood’s 83 affiliates will be affected by the cut, including the two in Idaho and Clallam County. The organization says Komen funds have provided 170,000 clinical breast exams nationwide.
“Komen got bullied by anti-choice politicians,” says Kristin Kristen Glundberg-Prossor of Planned Parenthood of the Great Northwest, which supports clinics in Washington, Idaho and Alaska, from its office in Seattle. “It’s a shame these two incredibly strong women’s organizations, both working to prevent cancer, have been forced into opposing positions by anti-choice forces determined to harm Planned Parenthood.”
No one at the Seattle offices of the Susan G. Komen Foundation For the Cure would comment on the cutoff of cancer screening funds. But the foundation’s national office issued a statement by email. The statement reviews Komen’s goals and accomplishments and its investments in community health programs ($93 million in 2011) including 700,000 mammograms. Without reference to the anti-abortion politics involved, the statement from Komen spokesperson Leslie Aus says, “We must continue to evolve to best meet the needs of the women we serve and most fully advance our mission.”
Sara Kiesler, media representative for Planned Parenthood Votes, the advocacy arm of the organization in Washington, called the Komen Foundation decision depressing. “Cancer has no party affiliation,” Kiesler said. “Cancer is neither pro-choice nor anti-choice.”
U.S. Sen. Patty Murray expressed disappointment that “politics is once again coming between women and their health care needs.” Murray said the heart of the issue is what she termed a “shameful investigation of Planned Parenthood by House Republicans trying to score political points and appease their right-wing base.”
In statements to the press, Komen’s Leslie Aun acknowledged that the cancer screening funds are being cut under the organization’s new rules cutting off grants to any group being investigated by authorities at the local, state, or federal level. Planned Parenthood falls under the prohibition because of a demand by Republican Rep. Cliff Stearns of Florida that Congress investigate Planned Parenthood to see if public money has been improperly spent on abortions. Planned Parenthood says more than 90 percent of its health care is preventative, including breast cancer screenings, birth control, and prevention of sexually transmitted diseases.
The cutoff of Planned Parenthood anti-cancer funds comes only months after Komen installed a new and strongly anti-abortion vice president, Karen Handel, who ran for governor of Georgia in 2010, on an anti-Planned Parenthood pledge.
Following the Komen Foundation announcement, a Texas couple, Amy and Lee Fikes, announced a $250,000 grant to help fill the gap in cancer-screening funds. Amy Fikes told national media the money will establish a Breast Health Fund at Planned Parenthood, “so that their health centers across the country can continue to put the real needs of women ahead of right wing ideology.”
Associated Press says the funds being cut from Planned Parenthood cancer screening work nationally came to $680,000 last year and $580,000 in 2010.
Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism. Become a member of Crosscut today!










Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feeds
Comments:
Posted Wed, Feb 1, 10:15 a.m. Inappropriate
I feel terribly disappointed in the Komen foundation for taking this action and will no longer support them in any way. It's sad and shameful that this foundation has chosen to act in the interest of the American equivalent of the Taliban.
Posted Wed, Feb 1, 11:24 a.m. Inappropriate
"The cutoff of Planned Parenthood anti-cancer funds comes only months after Komen installed a new and strongly anti-abortion vice president, Karen Handel, who ran for governor of Georgia in 2010, on an anti-Planned Parenthood pledge."
Clearly, the leadership of Komen was already disposed to make decisions on the basis of politics and ideology--so it's not necessary to cite Congressional "bullying" as the reason for this decision. They clearly knew of Karen Handel's leanings, and made her part of their executive team anyway (almost certainly BECAUSE of those leanings, and not DESPITE them).
Sadly, this is more evidence of the effects, and effectiveness, of "infiltration" of organizations that historically have little or no political intent.
Heretofore, the Komen venture has been entirely aimed at broadening access to early detection and more effective treatment of cancer in women. This is a neutral, and entirely laudable, policy and financial aim.
Now, the organization has chosen to slip away from the neutral zone of finance and access, and join the right wing in one of the great background struggles of our time: That between those who insist on the freedom of American women to direct their own reproductive affairs, and those who would extirpate that freedom.
I wonder if Susan B. Komen is quiet or restless in her grave.
Posted Wed, Feb 1, 11:35 a.m. Inappropriate
The next time there is a "race for the cure" on Whidbey (where I live), I'll be writing letters to the editors of all the local newspapers and posting on every website I can urging people instead to simply take the money they would have donated to Komen and give it directly to Planned Parenthood.
And does anyone know what the Komen ratios are for their fundraising and executive compensation expenses to dollars actually used for services?
Posted Mon, Feb 6, 10:39 p.m. Inappropriate
Susan G. Komen for the Cure has done a lot for the battle against breast and cervical cancer, but the organization's recent conclusion to pull its funding of Planned Parenthood has attracted crucial fire. Susan G. Komen CEO Nancy Brinker insists that the media's portrayal of events has been “a gross mischaracterization.” Last night KOMEN representatives vowed that they would never bow to political pressure. Funny then, that bowing to fundamentalist political pressure is what caused them to wind up with egg on the face to begin with. This is clearly political and has the Catholics all giddy. Susan Komen attempts to deflect heat from Planned Parenthood decision
Posted Thu, Feb 9, 3:50 p.m. Inappropriate
The (temporary) loss of funds to Planned Parenthood would be tragic were it not for the fact that Planned Parenthood doesn't actually do mammograms. They are just a pass-through organization for the funds.
Login or register to add your voice to the conversation.