A dream deferred: Showdown nears over Seattle's long-delayed World School

The Seattle district may soon revive its commitment to a central multilingual high school -- or send refugee students and their teachers bouncing across the city again.

A very modern Mercutio in 'Romeo and Juliet.'

Courtesy Svetlana Mamedova

A very modern Mercutio in 'Romeo and Juliet.'

Svetlana Mamedova and a scene (on computer screen) of her students' 'Twelfth Night,' set in old Tonkin.

Eric Scigliano

Svetlana Mamedova and a scene (on computer screen) of her students' 'Twelfth Night,' set in old Tonkin.

Mamedova breaks down actors' inhibitions with some hallway exercises.

Mamedova breaks down actors' inhibitions with some hallway exercises.

It’s nearing the end of the school day, when teachers and kids alike tend to be winding down, but Svetlana Mamedova’s drama class is going double-time. Not in the classroom; Mamedova has marched the kids out into the hall to do some warm-up, ice-breaking exercises. They’re passing an imaginary something around in a circle when the school’s principal, Martin O’Callaghan, and I stroll by, taking the tour. She invites us to join in. We walk on, but I duck back as soon as I can.

By then the class has returned to its room and plunged into rehearsal. The students are preparing their very first performances, which they have selected from an international collection of one-page micro-plays. Desale Wendie from Eritrea and Cristina Puric from Moldova are doing a read-through of “The Contrary Woman,” which seems to be set in the part of the world he comes from. They play husband and wife. Desale, who’s newer to the English language, must repeat many of his lines to get the pronunciation right. Christina seems more poised and familiar with the language, but it is she who balks at the end, shrinking shyly when the reconciled couple are supposed to take each other’s hands.

Mamedova is used to cajoling kids out of the double shells of adolescence and incapacity in English. “Remember,” she says with a flourish, “it’s drama!” One of the Vietnamese girls in the class chimes in: “It’s okay, it’s not real.” Christina and Desale clasp hands — one more little triumph on the road to English proficiency, and into the strange multinational mix that is America today.

Mamedova, tireless and ebullient, is an irresistible mama diva. Her main gig is as an ELL (“English language learning,” formerly “English as a second language”) teacher, and she clearly revels in the cosmopolitan milieu that comes with it: “I’m from Tajikistan, but my family was Russian and Turkoman, as multinational as you can get,” she say proudly. But her great passion is clearly the theater component of that learning. From modest beginnings, she will work these kids up to performing a Shakespeare play in June, as her classes do twice each year, each time with a suitably cross-cultural twist. This year it’s As You Like It. Before it was Twelfth Night, set in 18th century Vietnam and performed around Têt, with costumes ordered from Vietnam. French students — descendants of the former colonial power — played Viola and the “Duke of Hue,” and a Chinese student played the pirate Antonio. Mamedova shows photos. They are spectacular.

She and her students kept A Midsummer Night’s Dream in old Greece, but made the fairies Chinese and used Greek and classical Chinese music as accompaniment. They set Romeo and Juliet in Seattle, with Mexican Capulets and Somali “Mohameds” for the Montagues, a Vietnamese Mercutio, a Belarussian Juliet with Iranian father, and a Muslim marriage ceremony. “The students really related to that,” she says. After performing nearly all the comedies, she’s contemplating another tragedy. “Maybe Macbeth – they all know about witchcraft. Or Othello. It’s so close for them.” Will Desane and Christina be ready?

Svetlana Mamedova’s polyglot theater class is a classroom refuge to warm the heart of even the most jaded educational scrooge. But that refuge is a precarious one, thanks to the chronic uncertainty hanging over the school that contains it.

Over the past three decades, the Secondary Bilingual Orientation Center (SBOC), recently rechristened the Seattle World School, has been a refugee itself, bouncing around the district’s surplus buildings — an afterthought for a district beset by many other, seemingly larger and more urgent issues and interests. It was founded in 1980 at the old John Hay Elementary building on Queen Anne, in response to a flood of refugees arriving from Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos. It moved the next year to the Sharples (now Aki Kurose Middle School) building in the Rainier Valley, which it shared with a last-resort program for students who had washed out of other high schools. In 2000 it moved back to the crumbling “Old Hay.”

"It has been frustrating that the district hasn’t been more decisive about [assuring the SBOC a permanent home]," says Seattle City Councilmember Tim Burgess, who lives across the street from Hay and remains an avid supporter of the program. "It’s been difficult for stability, and the natural growth and evolution of that program has been hampered by the uncertainty about space and leadership and curriculum."

Finally, in 2009, to the great relief of staff and supporters, the bilingual center moved to a central and location, the former Meany Middle School on the backside of Capitol Hill, that was supposed to be permanent. Then the legs fell out under that plan as well.

Underlying the quest for a permanent home is another long-deferred goal: to replace what has been a bilingual halfway house with a full multilingual high school. The Secondary Bilingual Orientation Center, like the elementary BOCs scattered around the district, is intended to speedily transition newly arrived immigrants into the mainstream. Students attend a maximum of three semesters, getting English and dual-language instruction but no course credits, and then move on to the general middle and high schools. That’s easier done with elementary pupils, who learn new languages more readily and face less complex coursework and narrower disparities in educational background. The hurdles get higher in later years, and the results in Seattle are stark: Only about half the students transitioning through the SBOC eventually graduate.

The previous superintendent, Maria Goodloe-Johnson, recognized the problem and commissioned an audit of the district’s bilingual programs by the Council of the Great City Schools,  an organization of large urban districts. The findings, delivered in summer 2008, were devastating: “The [Great Cities] team found the Seattle schools’ strategic approach to teaching English language learners to be ad hoc, incoherent, and directionless. [The program] consists largely of a series of disconnected activities pulled together under the heading of ‘bilingual education’ that are actually the by-products of the school system’s long-standing site-based management approach to reform, its student assignment program, its collective bargaining agreement, its desegregation strategy, its generally low-expectations for English language learners, and the state’s requirements for testing in English.” Staffing was “skeletal,” training weak, and services widely scattered. Seattle’s was “one of the weakest such programs” the council had ever seen. "In some ways, the school district does not have a program at all."

Meanwhile, the need was growing: a new wave of refugees had begun arriving in the country, following the easing of post-9/11 restrictions, and the Seattle area was a magnet for them. This article is not the place to rehash the perennial argument over whether bilingual programs or English immersion serve immigrant kids better (though some commenters will likely choose to do so). The answer may depend on age, on individual students and their exposure outside of school, and on the quality of instruction. “How would you do if you were suddenly dropped in the middle of a classroom in China?” O’Callaghan likes to ask. “There’s all kinds of research that supports one and the other approach. Finding good, reliable, consistent research is a challenge.”

Much research of late points toward the “world school” model — a full-credit, graduation-granting school combining rigorous academics with native-language support. In theory, world schools can become magnets, attracting nonnative speakers who want to learn the languages they employ. At the least, continuity through the high school years means that those who’ve learned more English can help those just starting out.


Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism. Become a member of Crosscut today!

Comments:

Posted Tue, Mar 27, 11:07 p.m. Inappropriate

You have to know the SPS map and look at all the moving parts. But a few things are clear as the district moves towards its next capital levy/bond. Where the World School, Nova and APP elementary north will end up are three of them.

1) The World School has waited long enough for their permanent home. It was to be Meany and Meany truly is the best site for them geographicallly. It is NOT a great building but that seems to matter little to them. To move them further south would only jeopardize their enrollment. It they had to be moved, they should be self-contained so the former African-American Academy building would be a good place. (Van Asselt is currently in there but they are a K-5 school in a K-8 building. Their old school could be fixed up and, as well, give them more distance from the other elementaries they currently sit too close to.)

Also, the World School's BEX money was a modest $14M (which went to Garfield's cost overruns) and now magically is down to $10M.

2) Nova - very few choices here but back to Mann. But their home on a hill could be refurbished nicely and be the home it should have been. Nova saves lives and is a valuable and needed program in our district. Their students perform very well.

3) APP elementary north. Split in two a couple of years back (with one part going to Thurgood Marshall), then split off last year and now co-locating with McDonald elementary in the old LIncoln building and now roiled by the investigation that came out last Friday of their principals, they are one tired community. They, too, deserved a permanent home but the trouble is, with the growth of the district, there are fewer options than ever.

westello

Posted Thu, Apr 19, 3:50 p.m. Inappropriate

Seattle Public Schools has never kept any commitment to any community. If the District promises something to students and families, you don't know what they will really do, but you know that the one thing they will not do is whatever they promised.

The District made a solemn promise the World School. They even took a board vote on it. They broke that promise, of course. Now the World School is caught again in the District's spin cycle. Why should anyone believe that the District will fix up Meany for the World School when that is exactly what the District promised - and then refused to do - three years ago?

The District is now caught up in the difficult work of undoing every decision that Maria Goodloe-Johnson and the previous Board ever made. They are doing it because every one of those decisions has proven wrong - just as the public told them the decisions were wrong when the Board and the superintendent were making them. The work is being made extra difficult because they are trying to do it without admitting that they made any mistakes and they are trying to do it without acknowledging the cost of those mistakes. As they re-open the schools they closed they don't want anyone to remember that they were the people who closed them, that they spent tens of millions to do it, that they disrupted students' educations, working relationships, and communities, or that it is costing tens of millions of dollars again to re-open the same buildings.

The District closed Meany and they should not have. Now they have no other building suitable for use as a middle school in that part of town. The District moved NOVA out of Mann - for no good reason - and now they have to renovate Mann and move NOVA back into it. NOVA was moved to Meany so that the space would not be available for Summit, a program that the District wanted to kill because it ran up transportation costs.

The World School projects its enrollment at about 600. The District is pretending that it will not grow beyond 400, leaving space for 700 middle school students in the building. Bear in mind that the building is now full with the World School sharing it with NOVA, a school with an enrollment of 330. The District's numbers don't add up. Good luck getting anyone from the District to talk about it.

The District is a mess. They are planning the BEX IV construction projects without first determining what programs need homes. The superintendent and her staff freely acknowledge that they have no process for finding homes for programs. They just shoe-horn them in wherever there is space available. Then they move them if that space closes up or is needed by someone else. There is no planning, no procedure, no process. It's all ad hoc. This is an acknowledged fact by the board, the superintendent, and her staff. It is also in direct violation of Board Policy, which is also an acknowledged fact by the board (who will not enforce the policy), the superintendent (who will not follow the policy), and the staff.

Dr. Enfield has promised that she will have a procedure ready by the fall of this year. Of course, she is leaving the job in the summer, so I'm not holding my breath.

coolpapa

Login or register to add your voice to the conversation.

Join Crosscut now!
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow Us »