Afternoon Jolt: Going to the candidates' debate

The day's winners and losers.

36th District candidate Sahar Fathi, center

36th District candidate Sahar Fathi, center

Today's winners: 36th District state House candidate Sahar Fathi 

As noted in Fizz this morning, we hosted a forum last night at the Phinney Neighborhood Center featuring all five Democratic Party candidates for the 36th District state house seat being vacated by Democratic Rep. Mary Lou Dickerson. 

Though the candidates, particularly newcomer Brett Phillips, were well-versed in policy details, we're making Sahar Fathi, an aide to Seattle City Councilmember Mike O'Brien, the winner for convincing (skeptical) us that her emphasis on racial justice  (in the affluent 36th — Queen Anne, Magnolia, Ballard, Bell Town, South Lake Union ... where she lives) was particularly relevant.

Not only did she squarely put environmentalism — typically ignored during recessions — back on the agenda by viewing it as a racial and social justice issue by connecting it to public transit ("environmentalism has a face" she said, undoing the conventional wisdom during economic downturns that we have to focus exclusively on "kitchen table" issues), but she hit our direct question about her identity politics out of the park.

We challenged her to name a piece of legislation that the Democratic caucus championed and pushed through that ignored the perspective of minorities and ended up being a detriment to communities of color. Fathi pointed to legislation — enacted, belatedly, in 2011  —  that reduced the maximum jail sentence for a gross misdemeanor from 365 to 364 days, protecting legal immigrants from deportation. That legislation, she said, should have passed sooner  —  and if she had been in the Legislature, she would have pushed to make it happen.

We also liked how she answered another one of our questions — which we put to all the candidates: Name an issue where you've "evolved."

"I didn't see transportation as a social justice issue," Fathi said. "Social justice and transportation advocates should be working together."

Here's what the other candidates said they'd "evolved" on.

  • Brett Phillips said he used to be a square on marijuana legalization. Not anymore. "I grew up learning that marijuana is bad for your health ... now I recognize that criminalizing marijuana is just modern prohibition."
  • Gael Tarleton said she used to think "creating equal access to equal opportunity" simply involved establishing groovy social programs. Now she realizes you have to make them accessible and relevant.
  • Evan Clifthorne said used to be a dogmatic college lefty on exporting coal ("There was a time when I would have rallied against it", but now he realizes that approach doesn't work and you have to "speak the language of the rest of the state"), which means fleshing out the issue in a way that tranlates into common goals.
  • Noel Frame said as a young woman growing up in red turf in southwestern Washington, she grew up seeing the labor movement as a bad guy, but now sees labor as one of the most important forces in society for creating equity.

About the Author

Erica C. Barnett was the news editor for Seattle's online news site, PubliCola, where she covered city hall, transportation, land use, and state politics. She had also been the news editor and city hall columnist for The Stranger. In 2007, the King County Municipal League named Erica its Government Affairs Reporter of the year. She can be reached at erica.barnett@crosscut.com.

Award-winning journalist Josh Feit founded and edited the online news site PubliCola, where he also did double duty as the state house reporter, covering the legislature in Olympia. Before that, for nine years, he was the news editor and political columnist at Seattle's alt-weekly, The Stranger. He can be reached at josh.feit@crosscut.com.

Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism. Become a member of Crosscut today!

Comments:

Posted Thu, May 17, 5:39 p.m. Inappropriate

Yeah she did!

Posted Fri, May 18, 9:04 a.m. Inappropriate

"We challenged her to name a piece of legislation that the Democratic caucus championed and pushed through that ignored the perspective of minorities and ended up being a detriment to communities of color. Fathi pointed to legislation — enacted, belatedly, in 2011 — that reduced the maximum jail sentence for a gross misdemeanor from 365 to 364 days, protecting legal immigrants from deportation."

How, exactly, does that legislation ignore the "perspective of minorities" and end up being a "detriment to communities of color"?

Knocked it out of the park? Sounds more like she fouled it off.

BlueLight

Posted Fri, May 18, 5:34 p.m. Inappropriate

So did you have them hold up signs that you couldn't see? Your track record on moderating debates quite frankly stinks. Therefore, neither your reporting of those debates, nor your conclusions about them, can be trusted.

NotFan

Login or register to add your voice to the conversation.

Join Crosscut now!
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow Us »