The buzz on an otherwise quiet food crisis

When half of all bees began mysteriously dying in the U.S. and parts of Europe and Asia six years ago, beekeepers and food growers took note. What’s happened since then? Are honeybees in recovery? And what about those watermelons, apples and cherries we can’t live without?

Corky Luster, at work with his bees.

Dave Schiefelbein

Corky Luster, at work with his bees.

Corky Luster is checking his bees. “My suit and tie is pretty much a veil and a hive tool,” he says. On a cool day he gives them sugar water to build up their resources. There’s a tapering of nectar just before it begins in earnest when blackberries bloom. “Now we’re going to add a box and I’m just going to put this box on top of the next box.”

 

Click on the player above or here to listen to the audio version of this story.

 

This is penthouse living for bees — four to five hives stacked on top of each other on the roof of Bastille Restaurant, one of many clients of Luster’s Ballard Bee Company.  By the peak of summer there will be up to 60,000 bees living in the stack.

“You don’t want to get caught with too few boxes," he explains. "You can end up with a swarm because the bees want to leave because it’s too crowded.”  But no worries.  These tiny golden Italian bees are gentle, says Luster. “Some people have kids that laugh and smile all the time. This is that kid, that hive.”

Luster learned beekeeping in 1983, but he didn't really get into it until later, when he stopped seeing bees in his own backyard. “I felt like every year it seemed there were less and less bees, so I decided to jump back into it.”

Today he manages 135 hives, but wonders how much longer he and others can stay in business. Six years ago as many as half of all bee colonies died in the U.S., parts of Europe, and Asia. Colony collapse disorder, as the problem is termed, destroys the bee immune system. Sick bees become so disoriented they can’t find their way home.

Food growers took note. Most fruits and vegetables rely on bees for pollination. Almonds are 100 percent bee dependent. Apples, cherries and watermelon close to 90 percent.

Researchers cite various causes for colony collapse disorder: viruses, parasites — and pesticides. If you study pesticide use in the U.S. there’s a progression of one chemical family replacing another, says Jay Feldman, Executive Director of Beyond Pesticides, a not-for-profit advocacy group.

“Rachel Carson wrote about DDT and organochlorine pesticides and their long residual life in the environment,” he notes. Though DDT was banned in 1972, Feldman says that the pesticide industry has continued to replace one set of chemicals with another. The latest approach is to inject chemical pesticides into seeds, which become incorporated into the vascular system of plants.

Called systemic pesticides, the most worrisome of these is clothianidin, which is expressed through pollen. The same pollen that bees transport from flower to flower. An estimated 94 percent of 92 million acres of corn planted across the U.S. is treated with clothianidin, which was introduced in 2003. Honeybees rely on corn as a source of protein. “What we’re seeing is the blanketing of large areas of agriculture with systemic chemicals that are picked up by those insects that are pollinating,” Feldman says. 

Clothianidin, manufactured by Bayer, is the subject of a legal petition filed by Beyond Pesticides, beekeepers and others.  The petition calls on the Environmental Protection Agency to suspend the registration that allowed Bayer to sell the pesticide before safety data was collected. It also asks Congress to exercise oversight authority.

The EPA is currently reviewing the pesticide, but the process may last through 2018. “So we have a failed regulatory process that’s allowed the introduction of this chemical without adequate questions answered,” explained Feldman. It's a failure that's still manifesting itself in the failure of the bee population.

This winter Luster lost half of his bees. “I feel like we’re at a tipping point in this crisis," he says. "Any industry – if this was dairy, if you said I just lost half my cows you’d have the National Guard running out there to see what was going on. So this is what beekeepers are up against.”

Corky Luster recognizes the failed regulatory process. “Until we get a lot of big corporations out of government there’s no way we’re going to have a clean slate or even fight on if this should be allowed or not.” Still, he's optimistic things can be turned around. 

Around the country, there’s been a resurgence in beekeeping and an explosion of people growing pesticide-free food. In Woodinville, 21 Acres, a Center for Sustainable Food and Living, offers a popular beekeeping class. At a recent meeting of the class, enthusiasm ran high among students: “Oh, I see the queen right here." "Oh my gosh. This is fabulous." "This bee’s a superstar." 

Beekeeping started as a hobby for students Keith and Claudia Haunreiter. Now their teenage son is hooked too.If we don’t have the bees and they’re getting poisoned, they’re struggling terribly because of pesticides and other issues – we don’t have bees, we don’t have some food,” explains Claudia Haunreiter. 

There’s a lot to learn and a lot at stake.

Green Acre Radio is brought to you with support from the Human Links Foundation. Engineering by CJ Lazenby. 


About the Author

Martha Baskin is an environmental reporter, whose work on the subject began with a project for the King Conservation District. Green Acre Radio was born shortly afterwards. She was one of the founding reporters for Pacifica's Free Speech Radio News and has been a contributor to the National Radio Project's Making Contact.

Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism. Become a member of Crosscut today!

Comments:

Posted Mon, Jun 11, 4:49 a.m. Inappropriate

"There’s a lot to learn..."

Like, for instance, that it is a parasite that is responsible for colony collapse?

http://zeenews.india.com/news/eco-news/suspect-in-bee-colony-deaths-found_780821.html

Maybe you should've blamed colony collapse on a shortage of tax money, or the War on Women, or the Koch Brothers, or the Citizens United ruling, or -ooh! - The One Percent!

BlueLight

Posted Mon, Jun 11, 8:32 a.m. Inappropriate

What part of insecticide is unclear? They kill insects; all insects. Bees are insects. I am not sure what percent of the pollen collected by bees comes from corn; it is mostly a wind pollinated crop. But there is certainly enough neonicotinamide in the high-fructose corn syrup that is often fed to bees. Yes, parasites play a role. But they have always been there. After all, if the parasite kills the bee, the parasite dies.
And if the parasite kills the bees, there should be dead bees in and around the hive. In CCD, the dead bees are missing. The answers are not yet clear. However, the new systemic pesticides clearly play some role. We can control that. Do you really want to take the risk of keeping the insecticide and losing the bees and about one third of your food?

adexterc

Posted Mon, Jun 11, 12:45 p.m. Inappropriate


Could the writer please give a simple sentence or two stating what the *current situation* is--that is, whether or not bees are recovering from the collapse, if the collapse is continuing, or if it has flattened out?

There's really nothing new in this article. Giving a perspective on what is happening right now--recovery or not--would be very useful information. The writer says that there's a resurgence in beekeeping nationally, which is good information that I'm happy to hear. Also, Luster expresses his opinion that we're at a tipping point. Good, but neither statement is news to people who have been following this story. Some hard data on the current situation would be newsworthy.

I appreciate your effort to report on this, and your response!

Lindy

Posted Mon, Jun 11, 8:40 p.m. Inappropriate

@BlueLight

Pesticide(s) lowers/destroys bee's immune system. Bee is no longer able to ward off parasite. Bee becomes infected with 'Varroa destructor'. Bee dies. Varroa mite thrives, multiplies exponentially and the virus becomes the "most widely distributed and contagious insect viruses on the planet". Kills more weakened bees.

Cause & effect.

Regurgitated right-wing rhetoric is just easier, isn't it, BlueLight? That way you don't have to actually think! Fox News tells you what you need to know...

beno

Posted Tue, Jun 12, 12:42 p.m. Inappropriate

citation, please.

BlueLight

Posted Thu, Jun 14, 1:35 a.m. Inappropriate

There has been A LOT of press recently concerning studies which document the detrimental effect on bees associated with neonicotinoid pesticides.

Recently released studies [see citations below] have replicated colony collapse through low exposure levels of neonicotinoid pesticides.

In fact, France has recently announced that it was banning one such pesticide, Sygenta. See here: http://news.mongabay.com/2012/0604-hance-bees-france-ban.html

Citations:
[1] Chensheng Lu, Kenneth M. Warchol, Richard A. Callahan. In situ replication of honey bee colony collapse disorder. Bulletin of Insectology. 2012.

[2] D. M. Eiri, J. C. Nieh. A nicotinic acetylcholine receptor agonist affects honey bee sucrose responsiveness and decreases waggle dancing. Journal of Experimental Biology, 2012; 215 (12): 2022 DOI: 10.1242/jeb.068718.

[3] M. Henry; O. Rollin; J. Aptel; S. Tchamitchian; M. Beguin; F. Requier; O. Rollin; A. Decourtye. A Common Pesticide Decreases Foraging Success and Survival in Honey Bees. Science. 2012.

[4] P.R. Whitehorn; S. O’Connor; D. Goulson; F.L. Wackers. Neonicotinoid Pesticide Reduces Bumble Bee Colony Growth and Queen Production. Science. 2012.

Login or register to add your voice to the conversation.

Join Crosscut now!
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow Us »