Can two men save thousands of acres of Kitsap Peninsula forest?

Port Gamble and its surrounding forests have been logging territory for more than a century. Owner Pope Resources is willing to strike a deal with local tribes that would conserve thousands of acres of forestland. If the two sides can agree on terms.

(Page 2 of 5)

Indian rights were an afterthought, and their land claims were addressed retroactively by treaty — a process stacked against the tribes, who had no concept of private property. Through the 1855 Point No Point Treaty, the S'Klallam, Skokomish and Chemakum ceded rights to over 750,000 acres for $60,000 in government services, and agreed to move to a shared 3,800-acre reservation. Most of the S'Klallam eventually returned to old village sites, including Point Julia, which the federal government finally bought from Pope & Talbot in 1938 to create what is now the Port Gamble S'Klallam Reservation. (Today, there are three recognized bands of S'Klallam –– at Port Gamble, Jamestown and Elwha, spread around Hood Canal and the Olympic Peninsula.)

Such treaties did, however, guarantee Indians' rights to fish at "usual and accustomed grounds … in common with all citizens of the United States." But population growth, the advent of industrial fishing and canning, dams, and other development soon depleted fisheries and shellfish stocks and destroyed habitat.

In the 20th century, Washington established fishing seasons, licenses and catch limits, and game wardens began arresting Indians who didn't follow the state rules. By the 1960s, Billy Frank Jr. had become a tribal activist who was arrested more than 50 times, and he and others had elevated Indian fishing from subsistence living to civil rights action.

The scuffle landed in western Washington's U.S. District Court where, in 1974, Judge George Boldt upheld the 1850s treaties, decreeing that Indians were entitled to basically half of all of the fish in their historic harvesting areas, known as usual and accustomed, or U&A, grounds. The decision –– often compared regionally to Brown vs. Board of Education –– gave local tribes unprecedented legal clout. White fishermen staged bitter protests, hanging effigies of Boldt outside the courtroom. In the 1990s, another federal judge ruled the tribes also had rights to half of the shellfish in the U&A grounds.

The rulings made Northwest tribes co-managers with the state government of coastal resources. Today, the struggle to uphold treaty obligations includes ongoing legal challenges to ensure sustainable populations of salmon and other fish for tribes to harvest, as well as a range of restoration projects. Port Gamble S'Klallam hatchery workers spawn chum salmon eggs and raise juvenile coho salmon to sustain stocks for harvesting and recovery. They also plant millions of Manila clam seeds and have recently planted kelp beds to restore native oysters. (Other tribes are also succeeding: The Lower Elwha Klallam helped force the removal of the Elwha Dam in 2011, claiming it impeded salmon runs and violated their treaty rights.)

Meanwhile, by the 1980s, Port Gamble's halcyon days were over. Trucks and trains had replaced ships as the main transport for wood. The Navy and aerospace and technology industries had displaced timber as the region's driving economic forces. People working at Boeing and, later, Microsoft and other Seattle-area tech companies moved into growing bedroom communities, including the Kitsap Peninsula — a roughly hour-long commute via ferry and car. Since 1970, Kitsap County's population has more than doubled to over 254,000 people. Many new residents opposed large-scale logging in the local forests. With supply dwindling, the mill closed in 1995.

In the meantime, Pope & Talbot had birthed Pope Resources to manage and protect its Washington land resources. After Pope & Talbot filed for bankruptcy in 2007, Pope Resources assumed full control of -- and liability for -- the town and mill site.

Today, the company town looks much the same as it did when it was built. Idyllic, freshly painted late Victorian-style homes and perfectly manicured lawns still line its streets. It's a national historic landmark and a popular setting for weddings. But the nearly vacant 120-acre community — home to just 70 residents — feels eerie enough that best-selling author Gregg Olsen set a young-adult suspense series here, opening with a paranormal, cyber-bullying murder mystery that unfolds in the "deceptively picture-perfect" environs.

Other than special events and a few businesses aimed at tourists and sea kayakers, Puget Sound's last company town is a fiscal millstone for Pope Resources. As landlord, house painter, lawn mower and events planner, Pope loses $200,000 a year. Officials like to say they're the only timber company in the wedding business — and they're ready to get out.

Jon Rose discovered Port Gamble in the late 1980s. Raised in Connecticut, Rose, a civil-engineering graduate from the University of Vermont, moved to Washington for a job and was feeling homesick. When he saw the mill coughing out smoke, and the pitched-roof architecture of the houses, general store and church, he felt the place was a "slice of New England." Several years later, he landed a job with Pope Resources.

As more people have moved to the peninsula, Pope — still the largest landowner in Kitsap County — has converted some of its former timberlands into suburban neighborhoods, business parks and shopping areas. It has also brokered several conservation sales and easements on over 20,000 acres in Washington since 2008 to protect habitat and water resources.

At the same time, Pope is buying up forests in rural southern Washington and Oregon, where logging is more viable and the lands serve as long-term investments. It's part of a larger trend: The state's private forests have changed ownership at a staggering pace in recent decades, as timber companies have sold off forestlands for development and the timber market has eroded.

In 2007, Pope announced it would sell off about 7,000 acres in northern Kitsap County, including 3,300 acres of contiguous forest and two miles of undeveloped bay shoreline. The project — and the fate of the company town — fell to Jon Rose.

Rose, 50 with graying hair and a booming voice, is easy to talk to. For a land-development executive, he uses the words "dude" and "friggin' " a lot, and he proudly retains his acerbic Northeastern wit, joking: "Nobody this rude comes from the Northwest."

Rose saw an opportunity to preserve the company's local legacy, while still earning money for its shareholders. Even though the county had given him permission to zone thousands of acres into 20-acre lots, Rose proposed selling the intact parcels for conservation instead. Lacking development value, however, the land would have to be sold at a lower price. Therefore Pope would cluster 1,300 new homes on 1,000 acres in and around Port Gamble — enough growth so the town could survive without company patronage. The plan would protect and extend the popular trail network through the Pope lands, connecting historic towns around the northern end of the peninsula.

Rose rolled out his concept, the "String of Pearls," at a June 2007 community meeting that drew 530 people — "like Woodstock for this area," he says. Citizens embraced the idea, and business leaders discussed a burgeoning recreation economy, attracting weekend cyclists, hikers, runners, active retirees and other outdoor enthusiasts wanting to get away from Seattle.

"My vision is to have this area turn into a destination," says Linda Berry-Maraist, a city council member in nearby Poulsbo and a leader of the North Kitsap Trails Association, who was among the local government officials who initially endorsed the vision. At the Poulsbohemian coffeehouse, she says the String of Pearls seemed like a "phenomenal" way to accomplish that.


Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism. Become a member of Crosscut today!

Comments:

Posted Fri, Nov 30, 12:10 p.m. Inappropriate

I hope Pope, the S'Klallam, and Kitsap folks can get most of that land into conservation status. It's a tremendous opportunity.

Thanks for the reporting.

louploup

Posted Fri, Nov 30, 8:49 p.m. Inappropriate

This is one of Crosscut's best articles ever: knowledgeable, well-researched, balanced, with an accurate sense of history. And it's about something other than the dreary minutiae of Seattle City Hall politics. Kitsap County may seem far off because it's a ferry ride away. But you can stand on the shoreline at Suquamish and look across the bay at the Seattle skyscrapers.

woofer

Posted Fri, Nov 30, 11:53 p.m. Inappropriate

There's no turning back the clock and when both sides continue to play the history cards as though the cards are somehow the most accurate portrayal of the past, well it isn't going to resolve the issue. This is so typical of the way Indians and whites interact about issues. Both nod their heads and mouth the words out loud "I understand" but under their breath they add "I don't believe or trust you".

I, for one, want the water cleaned up and I don't care who does it, just do it. But I don't believe for one minute that the future of the waterfront land in question, if passed into Indian hands, won't be turned into a casino resort area. Indians aren't stupid and they realize with the right piece of property there's a ton of money to be milked from "us". This is that right piece of property. There's a bigger payoff from a casino then a clam bed. Sure they'll manage the resources but they won't pass up the chance to go greenback. It's called a diverse income portfolio.

Djinn

Posted Mon, Dec 3, 12:24 p.m. Inappropriate

Dear louploup, woofer and others who enjoyed this story -- this story was original reporting and writing paid for and published by High Country News, a nonprofit independent newsmagazine that's been covering the American West for more than 40 years. The story originally appeared here:
https://www.hcn.org/issues/44.20/a-washington-tribe-and-a-timber-company-wrestle-over-a-forests-future

You'll find more great news, analysis and stories at hcn.org. Thanks for reading. Sincerely, Jodi Peterson, High Country News Managing Editor

Posted Mon, Dec 3, 6:43 p.m. Inappropriate

I htink Djinn is right.

I personally feel very uncomfortable with the continued "different" worlds of the native Americans vs. the rest of us interlopers. And, no, it doesn't make sense for us to go back, we can't undo that either.

But I look at casinos as a money maker, but they do nothing to enhance the so-called native ways of life. This is 2012. It's time to come together, and ensure equal opportunity in lives and careers for all of our children.

Posted Mon, Dec 3, 11:47 p.m. Inappropriate

Most Indians are heavy gamblers, it's been part of the culture long before we showed up. I've had presentations and show me tours cancelled because the elders wanted the bus for a trip to tribe XVR to play bone games. Some of the tours were to examine salmon enhancement methods on their reservation. Didn't matter.

To be fair not all tribes are this way but they are small in number, maybe less then 25%. Given the close proximity to large population centers, this property has casino written all over it.

Djinn

Posted Sat, Dec 8, 10:10 a.m. Inappropriate

These threads always seem to degenerate into petty stereotypical rants , and cynical statements that take the low road. Development is development, and if we are going to allow the incremental removing of natural habitat to continue, then the water quality and wildlife will continue to decline. If we protect our remaining shoreline, and clean up the industrial waste, then the environment will start to recover. Right now we are all losing, because when it is the environment V making money... We allow making money to dictate our decisions.
We're gambling with losing the whole ecosystem. All of us.

Blake

Login or register to add your voice to the conversation.

Join Crosscut now!
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow Us »