Dear Mayor: An eyewitness critique of Pioneer Square's homeless beating

Steve Banfield watched as two Seattle firefighters beat a pair of homeless men sleeping in Pioneer Square. His correspondence with Mayor Ed Murray on the subject.

Editor's Note: On March 16th, 2014, Hugh Steven Banfield wrote the following letter to Mayor Ed Murray and posted it on his blog. On Thursday, March 20th, he received a response, included here. Late last week, the mayor's office also directed the Seattle Fire Department and Seattle Police Department to respond directly to Banfield and others who expressed concerns. 

Dear Mr. Mayor,

I’m writing this, which I’ll post online and will also send to your office, in response to an incident that occurred in Pioneer Square after the Sounders game on March 15th. As a result, three people were arrested, one person was stabbed and several injured in a brawl that could have been prevented. The policies of your administration continue to encourage an environment in Pioneer Square that allows this violence to continue.

While both KOMO and KIRO have published their versions of the incident, I will share mine so I can make clear to you and your administration that the lack of police presence in Pioneer Square before, during and for an extended period after sporting events is putting both residents and visitors at risk.

While walking my dogs after 5 PM yesterday I passed very close to the firefighter’s memorial in Occidental Park. As I approached, I saw three people (two men, one woman) yelling at a homeless man lying on the memorial. As I passed, he responded when one [sic] of the men started yelling, “What did you say?” as he then rared [sic] back to punch the homeless man several times in the head and face. When the man tried to roll away to escape the attack, the aggressor kicked him several times.

While the attack continued, I called 911, reporting that I had just seen a man attacked, giving descriptions of everyone involved and that, unless police arrived quickly, this could escalate further. While I was on the phone with 911, the second man of the original three got into a fight with another homeless man, taking the homeless man’s walking stick from him and beating him with it. The homeless rallied around to protect the victims and after a lot of yelling, shoving and some tense moments, the attackers left north through the square towards Washington.

By 5:17 p.m. I had given my information to the 911 dispatcher, encouraged them to come quickly and given them my phone number to follow up.

Then nothing happened.

I didn’t expect a rapid police response. I’ve called 911 before to report other fights on Occidental and never seen police arrive in a timely fashion. So again this time I waited. I followed the three people north through the square with the goal of capturing a license plate number if they were going to get into a car, but they (apparently) went into McCoy’s Firehouse Bar*.

A few minutes later, I saw them return to Occidental to yell at a different group of men, screaming about “moochers” and “living off my tax dollars.” After I saw them leave the area again and no police had arrived, I decided to continue my walk with my dogs south along Occidental. It was by now approximately 5:25 or 5:30.

Looping back for home a few minutes later I saw police cars moving west on Main and Washington. I approached because I wanted to be able to give the officers any assisting information I could after my 911 call. When I arrived I saw this scene.

Image

Image

These were taken at 5:40. It shows two homeless men being questioned on the curb, the stick from the earlier beating on the ground next to them, and the female and one of the male aggressors in the street. The man is bleeding from what were explained to me later were stab wounds from a third altercation between the aggressive visitors and the homeless. The man wrapped in the “white” blanket in the first photo is the original victim, who was beaten and stomped for sleeping on the monument.

A homeless man was beaten and no police cars arrived. When one of the attackers was stabbed, four police cruisers, two ambulances, a fire truck and several fire department supervisor cars all arrived within minutes. After all the damage is done, is this your definition of appropriate response?

Image

Mr. Mayor, there will be police reports to read that will give a more complete view of events. I’m not going to speculate on the events immediately before the stabbing as I didn’t witness that fight. What I did see, both from the original altercation and the aftermath, convinces me that if your administration made active policing in Pioneer Square a priority, all of this could have been prevented.

Anyone who attends a Sounders, Seahawks or Mariners game is comforted by the large police presence. Officers are there directing traffic, coordinating and controlling the “march to the match” and as people leave the stadiums are there to keep things moving along in a safe and orderly fashion. Then where do they go? Once the games are done and the CenturyLink parking lots empty Pioneer Square becomes ignored by law enforcement until there is blood in the street. 

At the time of this incident there was a police cruiser parked at 1st and Washington. It was empty.

If there had been even a minimal police presence, then don’t you agree that the likelihood of a vicious attack like this would have gone down? If the first attack had been deterred, then the odds of the second, more serious fight which led to the stabbing would have also been prevented. Maybe the first attack would have happened even in view of the police, but they could have arrested the attackers. A man in handcuffs can’t start a new fight, nor get stabbed in response.

Without police in Pioneer Square to greet the highly intoxicated and volatile visitors who pour out of the bars, you are inviting violence.

I’m also not talking about a couple of mounted officers riding through, or four or five bicycle officers gathered on one corner. To be effective, the officers need to be walking throughout the park. Instead of standing together talking to each other, officers should be talking to citizens and making themselves visible. Engagement, not intimidation. They have to actually engage the community to provide a presence that will deter most violence.

Pioneer Square is a critical part of the downtown renaissance that is happening in Seattle. We can dig tunnels and knock down highways, build living space and open restaurants, but unless you make a commitment to keep Pioneer Square safe all the 12th Man signs in the world won’t matter.

Pioneer Square is the southern anchor of Seattle’s downtown, yet the policies of the Murray administration continue to give this critical neighborhood short shrift in public safety and law enforcement investment. Pioneer Square is a historic district, but what I saw yesterday makes me wonder if the Murray Administration has just written us off to the historic dangerous and violent reputation of the area.

When I tell people in other parts of King County that I live in Pioneer Square, their reaction is telling. Too often they think of the area as the equivalent of a third world conflict zone, a view fed by media reports that focus on violent confrontations such as yesterday’s. How long before people from other parts of the area think of coming to Pioneer Square is something they have to do in order to attend an event instead of something they want to do? Are we that willing to throw away all the positive emotion that came to PSQ and SODO through the Seahawks parade and celebration?

If you want Pioneer Square to be the southern parallel to the tech industry explosion of jobs, residences and businesses in South Lake Union then you, Mr. Mayor, must make an investment to keep everyone in Pioneer Square safe. Business can’t thrive in an area where you aren’t willing to make a commitment to safety.

Image

In closing Mr. Mayor, here is the last photo I took last night showing the police arresting the original attacker. The Seattle Police Department officers I dealt with were professional and courteous. They listened not only to my account, but to the comments and feedback of others in the area who saw the incident. I appreciate their service to our city. Support them, and the residents of Pioneer Square, by directing the police to make a presence in Pioneer Square a priority all day long on game days, and not just in response to assaults and calls for help.

* I found out this morning that the assailants left the Square and went into McCoy’s Firehouse where they asked the owner to call the police because “they had been jumped by 20 or 30 men” in the Square. Apparently several police officers responded and spoke to the men, but no action was taken because obviously the men left the bar went back to the Square and continued their aggressive behavior which led to the stabbing.

Sincerely,

Hugh Steven Banfield
Pioneer Square resident since 2010

- - -

Dear Hugh Banfield,

Thank you for the note. Mayor Murray released the following statement on March 17 regarding the March 15 incident in Pioneer Square.

"Fire Department Chief Gregory Dean and I have discussed the unfortunate incident that occurred at Occidental Park over the weekend.

Our firefighters are often the first responders for homeless individuals in crisis, and a key measure of their performance is how they treat our most vulnerable residents.

And we hold Seattle firefighters to high standard: whether they are on duty or off, Seattle firefighters are expected to treat every member of the community with care and respect.

Regrettably, that did not happen in this case — and, for that, we both apologize.

I have instructed Chief Dean to work with the City Attorney Pete Holmes and Personnel Director Susan Coskey to identify an outside investigator to conduct a full review of what occurred. I have asked Police Department Chief Harry Bailey to analyze SPD's response time after this incident was first called in. And I'm seeking the perspective of City Attorney Holmes and the labor relations department to assist Chief Dean in evaluating the disciplinary options he will need to consider.

I am also asking Chief Bailey for a review of the Police Department's staffing in Pioneer Square during professional sports games to make sure we have the police presence required to prevent violent behaviors from breaking out, and to be responsive and timely when they do.

Over the years, Pioneer Square's residents and businesses have asked for greater attention on public safety issues.

The unfortunate incident Saturday sheds light on this important request, and so over the next few weeks and months I will be meeting with businesses and social service providers in the neighborhood to work with them in ensuring that Pioneer Square is a safer and more welcoming environment for all people."

Please click here if you have further questions.

Sincerely,
Bennett Barr

Steve Banfield first moved to Seattle in 1993 and has lived in Pioneer Square since 2010. Steve is a long time Seattle technology industry veteran having worked for Microsoft, RealNetworks, Screenlife Games, Korrio and Medio, and is currently SVP & GM, Registrar Services at Rightside in Kirkland. He has a BA in Computer Science from Transylvania University and an MBA from Harvard Business School. He's also a photographer of people and scenes from around Seattle and the world. You can find him on Twitter at @stevebanfield.


Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism. Become a member of Crosscut today!

Comments:

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 4:22 a.m. Inappropriate

In addition to more Police in Pioneer Square, perhaps an examination of the policy that allows the homeless the pass out/sleep/camp on the streets is in order as well.

There is no excuse for the aggressive behavior of the individuals involved here. I assume that since these are fire fighters that Pete Holmes will make sure that there will be no favoritism in the prosecution of their crimes.

Unfortunately for Murray, the pattern of talking about action and not actually taking any action is a long standing tradition in Seattle.

Cameron

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 8:22 a.m. Inappropriate

Thank you Mr. Banfield for reaching out to city officials with your first-hand account and emphasizing how imperative it is to provide better police presence in the area, especially when large, inebriated crowds are present.

I especially enjoyed hearing how a seemingly able-bodied firefighter who is on disability calls others “moochers” and “living off my tax dollars.”

jeffro

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 8:23 a.m. Inappropriate

I'm sorry, but I cannot find any sentence in the text of this letter stating that these attackers were firefighters. It's hard to imagine the headline and Ed Murray's response being so off the mark, but it sounds like these were just three angry folks walking by the Firefighters' Memorial. Or is the Firehouse Bar known for serving SFD officers?

andro517

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 12:07 p.m. Inappropriate

Yes, this is sloppy journalism. Banfield's letter makes no attempt to identify the assailants, but obviously other sources have linked them to the Fire Department. Crosscut should have filled in the context that Banfield missed. Without it Murray's letter makes no sense. And if the assailants were indeed City firefighters, the cure obviously includes more than just more cops in Pioneer Square.

woofer

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 1:24 p.m. Inappropriate

"sloppy journalism" = Crosscut's normal standards.

ACJ

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 5:36 p.m. Inappropriate

Other news accounts identified the men as off duty firefighters, and the Fire Chief apologized stating that this type of behavior is not condoned in any way by the Seattle Fire Department. The lovely bride is employed at Amazon, also per other news accounts.

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 8:23 a.m. Inappropriate

@Cameron..."In addition to more Police in Pioneer Square, perhaps an examination of the policy that allows the homeless the pass out/sleep/camp on the streets is in order as well."

What part of 'homeless' don't you grasp? They are sleeping on the street because they have no home. There are few, if any, shelter beds available, because no one wants to pay taxes. Jobs are non-existent. You know the government justed enables these folks by giving them beds and food, right? Why pay taxes?

elbowman

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 12:05 p.m. Inappropriate

"They are sleeping on the street because they have no home"

Or because they chose to drink and do drugs.

Simon

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 5:43 p.m. Inappropriate

Or because they have mental health issues.

No matter why the homeless sleep on the street is no excuse for middle class middle aged cretins to beat on them.

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 8:33 a.m. Inappropriate

I currently work in Pioneer Square, and I have watched the fortunes of this valuable historic neighborhood ebb and flow since 1967. I would only add that in order to make a real difference, a police presence (preferably "beat cops") is required 24/7, not just after sporting events.

AN

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 11:34 a.m. Inappropriate

What I grasp, elbowman is that the City of Seattle tolerates homeless folks sleeping, passing out and peeing and taking dumps in Pioneer Square and public parks throughout the City. I also grasp that the tax dollars we are paying to address the issue is obviously being misallocated. How is the Ten Year Plan to end homelessness working out for you elbowman?

Cameron

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 12:07 p.m. Inappropriate

" Jobs are non-existent."

No doubt you support raising the minimum wage to make hobos more employable?

Simon

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 5:11 p.m. Inappropriate

"Seattle firefighters beat Pioneer Square's homeless"

No sir, you saw one off duty fireman beat one homeless. The only reason this is news is because for the vast majority of cases of attacks on the homeless it's other homeless or drug dealers.

Simon

Posted Mon, Mar 24, 5:33 p.m. Inappropriate

There were 2 firefighters, and one brought his wife, a well employed gal who work/ed at Amazon, to help kick the homeless man.

Posted Fri, Jun 13, 2:22 p.m. Inappropriate

Two off-duty city employees and a girlfriend.

ltfd

Posted Tue, Mar 25, 3:15 p.m. Inappropriate

After many decades of being a visitor to Pioneer Square to bar hop or visit galleries, I stopped ever going to that area after dark or in the hours after any sporting event about 10 years ago. It is not, and never was, the homeless folks I am afraid of. It's the drunks and partiers occupying the place.

Posted Tue, Mar 25, 11:39 p.m. Inappropriate

And about 15 years ago, the drunks started carrying guns, and using them in the streets after they got pushed out of the bars. The homeless and panhandlers were always scary, but never seemed as violent as the club drunk gangsters who took over.

Login or register to add your voice to the conversation.

Join Crosscut now!
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow Us »