Top of the News

Chosen and ranked by Crosscut editors. Click date for previous days.

Mouse over headline for description.

more top of the news

Advertisement

Advertisement


Most Commented

Crosscut articles of the past 10 days with the most reader comments.

Vision 2040 for Pugetopolis
(32 comments)

In Seattle, let the people 'chill'
(16 comments)

Seattle's money madness
(16 comments)

Our balls on ice
(12 comments)

Is Big Nanny running your town?
(10 comments)

A bicoastal newspaper crisis
(10 comments)

Time for a bus-fare reality check
(10 comments)

Walkability is nice, but it's not making us skinny
(8 comments)

Space tourism is nigh, but a new space age is not
(8 comments)

Who dies hard in the 'top-two' primary?
(6 comments)

Arts Beat »

Nov 6, 2007 12:00 PM | last updated Nov 6, 2007 8:00 PM
Advertisement
Advertisement

Update on Oregon Symphony: Five suggestions for new directions

An earlier article on the OSO generated lots of comment, and the plea for some positive suggestions. The author responds.

By Stephen Marc Beaudoin

I've received voluminous responses to my recent Crosscut article on the Oregon Symphony. Among the many emails and website comments, one refrain prevailed: "If you're going to criticize the Symphony, why not at least offer some suggestions or recommendations?"

Sure thing. Here are five things the Oregon Symphony might consider as it trims the organizational fat and reinvents itself for the future.

Get out into the community. The Symphony needs a bigger and more diverse audience. Portland neighborhoods and surrounding communities need more opportunities to hear and participate in first-rate classical music. The Symphony has recently begun engagement programs with the Eastern Oregon communities of La Grande and Cove, but what about engaging in residencies, partnerships, and chamber music concerts in Portland's urban core? Also, individual Symphony members could be empowered as a more active voice of the Symphony through Symphony-sponsored public school outreach, increased appearances on local concert series (or on the MAX streetcars?), and maybe even by blogging on the Symphony website.

Bring in a composer in residence. There are two bright, sophisticated, and articulate Oregon composers who could ably assist the Symphony in its programming of new music, and in finding the right balance and context in its contemporary programming. David Schiff – erudite writer/critic, accomplished composer, lover of jazz, and Reed College professor – is one. Robert Kyr – a smart composer based at University of Oregon, involved in the Oregon Bach Festival's contemporary programming – is the other.

Put the music in context. Sure, cute program titles like "Classical Elegance" and "Spanish Splendor" might be eye-catching. But if you look deeply into the musical, historical, and other thematic elements that tie Oregon Symphony programming together, you'll come up empty-handed. What if the Symphony organized its programming in a more creative and cogent way, offering audiences new ways of making connections between, say, a Haydn Symphony and a new work by Finnish composer Kaija Saariaho? What about trying out a mini-festival organized around a composer, a time period, a trend or a place?

Get clued into hot American classical artists, and bring them to Portland. I'm not sure where Oregon Symphony artistic administrator Charles Calmer gets his ideas about what guest artists to bring to Portland, but he might consider booking some of the best and brightest young American classical musicians on today's scene. Singers such as Joyce DiDonato, Nicole Cabell, and Thomas Meglioranza. Conductors including Marin Alsop (can you believe she spent several years at the Eugene Symphony and yet never appeared once in Portland?) or James Gaffigan (hugely talented assistant conductor in San Francisco). Pianists like Jeremy Denk, Pierre-Laurent Aimard or Bruce Brubaker; violinist Gil Shaham; or how about rock-star cellist Matt Haimovitz?

Use a pop figure as consultant and spokesperson in a full and meaningful way. Forgive me for not stating this before, but I'm a huge Thomas Lauderdale (of Pink Martini) fan. Since publishing last week's screed, I've been gently reminded of his classical background and his deep history with the Oregon Symphony. That doesn't make me less skeptical about how his great talents will (or will not) be fully utilized by the Symphony – that remains to be seen. Let's have his exciting and singular new ideas.

  • Stephen Marc Beaudoin is a musician and arts writer based in Portland.
Comments
The OSO needs a new hall
Report a violationPosted by: partial observer on Nov 6, 2007 4:03 PM
Mr. Beaudoin,

Those are fine suggestions, but the NUMBER ONE issue plaguing the Oregon Symphony was alluded to in your previous article: the symphony is playing in a movie theater that was never designed to be a concert hall, and was not modified properly when the orchestra moved in in 1984.

I have heard concerts in the Schnitz, and have played onstage with the Oregon Symphony. As you point out, the orchestra is indeed playing very well these days. But when one sounds in note in that hall, it goes "thud" and nothing happens to it. There is no mystery, no warmth, no presence. Many of the main floor seats under the balcony are truly wasted; very little sound gets there at all. It is as though you handed Itzhak Perlman a student violin. He would try valiantly to get a sound out of it, and mostly fail. The OSO is daily battling against a faulty instrument.

Nashville, Tennessee, a city much smaller than Portland, just built a state-of-the-art shoebox shaped European style hall for their orchestra. It took five years from conception to completion. On the West Coast, Seattle and Los Angeles have new halls, and San Francisco's has been updated. Orange County (!) has a new hall. Vancouver BC's Orpheum was also a former movie theater, but with better initial dimensions and far better conversion to concert hall requirements--a rigid shell to project the sound, for example. The OSO desperately needs a dedicated, acoustically perfect concert hall. Until that happens, many of your fine suggestions regarding soloists, repertoire, etc will still fall on partially "deaf" ears. Those aren't the kind of ears connected to hands that reach into pocketbooks to support a flagship arts organization.

Roger Kaza
Houston Symphony Orchestra
Cabell and Meglioranza
Report a violationPosted by: sbeaudoin on Nov 7, 2007 9:31 PM
After chatting with a few folks about this, it was brought to my attention that both Cabell and Meglioranza have in fact performed with the Oregon Symphony previously (before I arrived in town): Cabell as soloist in a Mahler 2 conducted by Kalmar in May 2004; Meglioranza in a Messiah conducted by Bernard Labadie in December of 2004. They've progressed strongly in their careers since then, and are both worth bringing back.
Cellist Matt Haimovitz
Report a violationPosted by: SillimanDodge on Nov 8, 2007 1:34 PM
Speaking of young American artists, if you want to catch Matt Haimovitz, he'll be at Border's in the Mohawk Bld on SW 3rd at 1 pm Friday Nov 16. Edmund Stone of All Classical 89.9 is reading Shakespeare and Matt is playing from his After Reading Shakespeare series.
inciting dialogue
Report a violationPosted by: evanmk on Nov 19, 2007 1:33 PM
Today I also read David Stabler's take on the subject as well as Charles Noble's responses to both articles. Differences in opinion aside, I just wanted to say that I'm glad these ideas are being communicated.
Advertisement
Advertisement

Sign up for Crosscut's free weekday newsletter e-mail.
About Crosscut
Advertising Info
Crosscut's list of RSS feeds.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Crosscut »
Crosscut Seattle is an online newspaper for the Pacific Northwest, including Washington, Oregon, Idaho, and British Columbia. It's a guide to local and regional news, a place to report and discuss news, and a platform for new tools to convey news.

• More about Crosscut

Contact Crosscut

Tools

Sign up for Crosscut's daily newsletter
About Crosscut
Advertising Info
Crosscut's list of RSS feeds.
Advertisement