The My Ballard blog reports that the landmark Manning's/Denny's diner was demolished early this morning. A demolition permit was issued by the city just last week.
The diner was granted city landmark status earlier this year. The Landmarks Board later decided that preserving the building was not economically feasible for the owner, Benaroya, clearing the way for its destruction.
The demolition comes almost exactly a year to the day after Crosscut first reported that the building might have historic significance. It was designed by prominent Bay Area architect Clarence W. Mayhew in 1964 for the Seattle-founded Manning's, a West Coast coffee company and restaurant chain founded at the Pike Place Market 100 years ago.
The diner had been saved from demolition once before, in the mid-1980s, when it was taken over by the Denny's chain. It had become a familiar and much-loved neighborhood feature, and a hang out for old Ballard's senior citizens.
Architectural historians found the building to be a fine and rare regional example of Googie roadside architecture, but the building defied easy description. It's roof line suggested Scandinavian and Polynesian influences. It also resembled a pavilion from the 1962 Seattle World's fair. When it was built, it was referred to somewhat humorously as "Ballard's Taj Mahal."
The landmark designation for the diner was hailed by many preservationists as a victory for mid-century modern architecture preservation. But it was also widely ridiculed by those who didn't like the building and felt that saving it lowered the bar too far on what can be considered historic or a landmark. For many, the Landmarks Board's decision to save it, then allow it to be demolished calls into question the fundamentals of the landmarks process.
Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism by becoming a member of Crosscut.com today!

Print
Email






Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feeds
Comments:
Posted Tue, Jun 24, 10:30 a.m. Inappropriate
Amend the Ladmarks Preservation Ordinance and....: Yes the process needs to be re-thunk! There are several places in the Ordinance that can be improved upon without showing a bias towards owners or preservationists. Just making it more fair and treating everyone like good citizens is the simple guiding goal. We need to come out of the dark ages of preservation, fearing owners who will only want to demolish their landmarks, and see them as partners in preserving the character of our community. And the owners need to see the process as helping them get the just compensation for the long term responsibility of preservation. Anyone who says that the Ordinance is just fine has their head in the sand. Historic Preservation as a public policy has been a snapshot of a moving target. Now is no exception.
Sally Clark and her Council Committee is going to take the first giant step in creating fairness. While it's been taking too long to start this discussion, Sally is very interested in creating an Historic Preservation Incentives task Force (which was recommended by both owners and preservationists). It's primary task will be to look to recommending new incentives that deal with properties all over the city. Sally wants to have those new incentives before the Council by the end of this year. If she doesn't get it going soon, this date may be problematic. GO SALLY GO!
There should also be another Task Force to reexamine the Ordinance itself. This could be accoumplished rather quickly so that any reciommended changes/addicitons, could parallel the timing of the recomendations of the Incentives TF.
The bottom line is to make sure that the Preservation Policies of our great City brings us closer together rather than be polorized by them.
I'm optomistic!
Let's get going!!!
Art
Posted Wed, Jun 25, 12:18 p.m. Inappropriate
a building worthy of saving defined-: I can understand and fully support wanting to preserve good architecture but let's define same. In this long-time architect's book, a building worthy of saving on desireable, useful property has to be attractive and well-designed in the first place and well-used by the community as time goes on. Jerry Gropp Architect AIA