Writing in this space last summer, I observed that the new president of Western Washington University, Bruce Shepard, should face relatively favorable circumstances when he arrived in September. A nasty faculty-union dispute had been settled, he had a free hand to name assistants, and the climate on campus was optimistic.
That was before the economic crash of the fall, and threatened state budget cuts of 13 percent for all higher education.
Last week, Shepard made his first headline decision. He eliminated the WWU football program after 105 years, the last 10 as a member of NCAA Division II. Aside from players, coaches and a few loyal Viking alums, it was a yawner, a no-brainer and further evidence of how far colleges have come under Title IX, the federal program that sought to make women's athletics roughly on a par with those for men.
Western, at least in my 14 years on its faculty, never had a football culture. Most students were apathetic, faculty rarely attended games, and Whatcom County evinced little interest despite a passion for high-school games. Aside from the rivalry with Central Washington University, a football game rarely drew more than 2,000 fans. When Shepard's decision was announced in Thursday's Bellingham Herald, not a single reader posted a comment.
The Saturday tailgate culture of big-school football had no grip on a campus with no fraternities or crowds of community backers available in larger cities. Western students prefer active snow sports and basketball; Title IX brought women's sports into the limelight, and Western women in crew, volleyball, and basketball developed excellent records and lots of campus support.
As a professor, I found Western athletes as motivated and conscientious as other students, and never heard a colleague complain of pressure on athletes' grades. Sports seemed to be in perspective, with only the size of the football program drawing criticism.
Compared to the other 15 intercollegiate sports at Western, football looms large in budgets as well as player weights. Western's athletic program gets about $1.05 million in state aid annually, university officials say. Dropping football will save roughly $450,000 a year, and allow the other sports to survive. Travel costs continue to rise, and only two of Western's conference opponents are in-state.
When Western opted to join NCAA Division II in 1998, there was concern, particularly among faculty, that it was a step toward big-college athletics, with all the costs and hoopla that Western had previously avoided. That's unlikely now, although small schools such as Gonzaga and Seattle University compete with the big guys in basketball. The culture at Western is not encouraging to such a move, and Shepard is keen enough to grasp that and use the budget squeeze to trim a program that had not paid its way in many years and had a limited support base.
Those "other sports" that hardcore jocks disparage, such as volleyball, crew, and soccer, should prosper from the departure of the 800-pound gorilla. Other small colleges that still offer football may begin wondering when the revolution will arrive at their gates.
Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism by becoming a member of Crosscut.com today!

Print
Email





Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feeds
Comments:
Posted Mon, Jan 12, 1:04 p.m. Inappropriate
The fact that the story drew nary a comment on the Bellingham Herald is more of a comment on the rampant lack of interest in the Bellingham Herald than the football program. A story in the Seattle Times -- a publication where most student athletes at Western hail from -- actually drew hundreds of comments. Many of those expressed profound disappointment that athletes from state high schools who had talent that was not Division I talent are running out of places to play under scholarship. It's beyond question that there's not much of a "football culture" at Western. To me, the fact that the university could field a team and avoid that very "culture" was one of the great things about the program. You can make a sound argument for dropping the program. But purely line-item budgeting isn't a good one. By that measure, Western, which doesn't have much of a Shakespeare culture, either, would be issuing pink slips to English professors. The program did exist in the shadows, somewhat, largely because Western had no place to play on campus, and it's games were contested on a city field. But it had a long tradition, and was led by a dedicated bunch of kids and coaches who deserved at least a chance to help garner support to keep it going, rather than the blindsided shutdown they received.
Posted Mon, Jan 12, 3:24 p.m. Inappropriate
Now if Western could only get rid of it's profoundly useless Journalism program. Is it hard to be this out of step, bitter and useless Floyd? You are cheering the demise of a schools athletic program, does that make you feel better? Do you feel superior for never having supported the Football program at your former school? You truely are a small person to delight in the misfortune of others.
Posted Tue, Jan 13, 8:03 a.m. Inappropriate
Floyd, how could you ever offer a "cheer" for a decision of this magnitude, which impacts a Viking Football community of thousands, to be made with absolutely no dialogue or opportunity to offer a solution by those who have demonstrated a sincere effort to help. How would you feel if the school administration, in their infinite wisdom, announced tomorrow they were dropping the journalism department in favor of "ensuring excellence" in other fields of study without any consultation within the department. I doubt you would be offering a hearty cheer. For those interested in efforts to develop an opportunity to save the program please proceed to www.savewwufootball.com for more details.
Posted Tue, Jan 13, 8:59 a.m. Inappropriate
Floyd,
For an educated man, your short sightedness and lack of information is astounding. Your quote that "Aside from players, coaches and a few loyal Viking alums, it was a yawner". How dare you undermine the players and coaches of that program and speak as if it is an extra-cirricular activity with no value to the university. There are thousands of football alums and supporters, none of which ever had a voice in this issue. I'm not talking about a voice last week, or even earlier in the fall... this budget issue in athletics is a result of consistent mismanagement of the budget over a number of years. Its a leadership issue Floyd. The athletic department does not have a vision for their programs (football included, not exclusive). By simply raising awareness of the issue before it crests, WWU would have gained the necessary support before it ever became a problem of this magnitude. WWU attendance for football games is in line if not ahead of most all small college football programs whos stadiums are off campus. To incinuate that the community supports basketball more is laughable. Regardless of the sport and its success WWU has always had a loyal following, but never a big one. This isn't all about dollars and cents. Its about the opportunity to develop a diverse group of young men who along with the rest of the athletic department perform better academically that the normal student body. Football is not an 800 pound gorilla Floyd, its the very fabric that helped define the athletic program and the university for over 100 years. Believe it or not, very few kids go to WWU for the journalism program. Many, many more however, go to be a part of the athletic programs at WWU of which football as you pointed out is the largest team. To that end, students and alums both take pride in their school. A school with fantastic academic and athletic accomplishments alike, but where most of the national recognition comes from athletics. You may not have been in the stands Floyd but along with success in our other sports, football was ranked #1 in the country in 1995. We competed in the national championship game in 1996. We have had NFL players, CFL players, and most importanly we have developed business leaders, teachers, coaches, and men that are impacting our communities more that you will ever open your eyes to realize.
This decision is a mistake, period. As mentioned earlier, the athletic program has had a phenomenal amount of success over the years. Great coaches, great athletes. Sometimes there were a lot of financial resources and sometimes there weren't. This is economic period while unprecented, will still be a temporary in the big picture. The decision to cut away 100+ years of football and eliminate 100 more is not, and that Floyd is a shame.
-Jason
aThose "other sports" that hardcore jocks disparage, such as volleyball, crew, and soccer, should prosper from the departure of the 800-pound gorilla. Other small colleges that still offer football may begin wondering when the revolution will arrive at their gates. yawner
Posted Tue, Jan 13, 9:51 a.m. Inappropriate
Floyd,
The article written by Joe Sunnen, sports reporter at The Bellingham Herald, drew dozens of comments on Thursday and was one of the most viewed stories of the day (it was second to the floods; if you'll recall Ferndale and other communities were being threatened by cresting river water at the time). The follow-up stories on Friday and Saturday drew quite a bit of comments from online readers.
The short Associated Press story, which was on The Bellingham Herald web site for a brief period of time, drew no comments.
Posted Tue, Jan 13, 10:28 a.m. Inappropriate
rjudd,
I appreciate your passion for the program, and it is indeed a sad story. But to compare the football program to an English professor is ludicrous - the university is in place to teach, period. Sports are a perq; incredibly expensive sports with little student or community support are a perq that given the cuts facing state universities everywhere was apprently just no longer a possibility. We all feel for those kids, but your own points about cost, lack of student support, etc. tell the whole story.
Posted Tue, Jan 13, 12:33 p.m. Inappropriate
Floyd-
I am at a loss as to how you can make a judgement about how Western has not had a football culture? Clearly you did nothing to support the program or do much investigating into the "football culture" in your 14 years at the school. In fact, there is a large group of football supporters on campus. Although attendance at games was usually disappointing, I am not sure that is only way we should measure a program. Shouldn't a state University such as WWU offer well rounded curricular and co-curricular opportunities such as football AND journalism? Can't we all just get along?
As for the not so neutral_observer, you seem like you have been in the lab too long. The University experience should be about a lot more than teaching - funny that you don't even mention learning - maybe that isn't a priority for you either.
It makes me sad to see all of the smug comments and near celebrations from the academia community in relation to this issue. The reality is that we should all support each other when faced with these difficult budget related decisions - who knows, your precious program could be next.
Posted Tue, Jan 13, 1:08 p.m. Inappropriate
Readers may be interested to know that Shakespeare culture is very much alive on Western's campus. The English department can't offer enough Shakespeare courses, which fill quickly at the beginning of each registration period. Indeed, English is the largest major on campus with over 520 majors. Many students, English majors and students from across the campus, want a Shakespeare course before they graduate but cannot regiser for one due to limited resources. Of course, any account of Shakespeare on campus would have to encompass all that goes on the Theater department as well!
Posted Tue, Jan 13, 10:29 p.m. Inappropriate
I agree with sir79, why do professors like Floyd find joy in a 100 year old tradition (like football) go away? 83% of the students graduate. Many former football alumni, like me go on to receive graduate degrees (mine from Western).
It amazes me that you can have people like Floyd, who believe they are well informed speak rubbish and not understand that much of the problems he describes in the uniformed editorial are problems associated with the Athletic Administrative level, not football problems. A lack of vision and passion in that office have lead us to this place.
I wish that professors like Floyd could understand the friendships and lifelong bonds WWU football creates. It creates leaders in the communities around the country and state.
This editorial lacks understanding both the football program and the long term problems that lead us to this poor decision by the current administration.
This decision did not ensure success of other athletic programs, it weakened MY great school. One that I was proud to represent. One that many of us bled for.
It is so disappointing to see articles like this. It just makes me sad that someone will read this and believe this Floyd character knows anything about the subject.
Educate yourself and go to...
www.savewwufootball.com
Posted Wed, Jan 14, 1:29 p.m. Inappropriate
Mr. McKay,
As a former student athlete at Western I find it sad that a faculty member would cheer a decision to eliminate a University program. As a student at WWU I certainly did not agree w/ all of the Universities policies or programs but, I did not go out of my way to cheer or push for their demise.
I currently teach at a state high school that is extremely successful in both our academics and athletics. This does not happen by accident. It starts from strong leadership at the top and a dedicated staff who realize that by supporting other programs, they do not take away from their own. WWU appears to have neither strong leadership or a staff/faculty that is confident in their own programs.
Eliminating the football program has only taken away from the Western experience; not added to it. It was the wrong decision.
SWS75
Posted Wed, Jan 14, 5:45 p.m. Inappropriate
Based upon the comments you made in this editorial your horizon on this matter is very limited. Besides being riddled with snide stereotypical quips you present no real tangible argument to support your points. To be quite honest with you, the second biggest failure of the University that I can see is how a 14 year professor can write such a polemic and fact-less piece.
Posted Wed, Jan 14, 6:48 p.m. Inappropriate
Dear Floyd Mckay;
Using your arguments (albeit unfounded) of "apathetic" and the ability to have "enviced little interest from the community" could we turn those things towards journalism. With recent financial troubles especially in the print world, could we not say that the journalism department is unable to move the apathetic populous, and unable to envice interest from the community. If we did take such a heartless stance we could only conclude that the president of the university needs to cancel the Journalism department effective immediately.
Mr. Mckay as a former football player and part of the 83% that graduated I am concerned that the university keeps a program that supports people who spew such vile (yourself) and cancels a program that teaches sportsmanship, competition, and prepares men to be winners.
Posted Thu, Jan 15, 9:02 p.m. Inappropriate
Floyd,
As a Western J-school grad ('85) and former Western football player ('81, '82) I was saddened to see a member of a department I've always adored cheerleading the demise of a long-standing university program, athletic or otherwise, in a budgetary crisis.
I'm especially troubled that a journalism instructor would so wholeheartedly support a decision made in virtual secrecy by a handful of university administrators, with no opportunity for campus- and community-wide discussion, with no media coverage that might have shaped events differently, and with no opportunity for those who care most about the program to intervene on its behalf. That wasn't how I was taught to practice journalism at Western.
Football at Western has often been a quirky mix of tradition and ambivalence, an apt reflection of the overall university. The fact that players don't walk the campus like living Gods or that the stands aren't always packed for each game doesn't strike me as an unpardonable sin. It strikes me as refreshingly sane.
I'm hopeful the program can be saved, and that it will come back stronger than ever. But regardless of what happens, the century-old fraternity of Western football players and coaches deserves better than the ringing endorsement of a scapegoating mindset that might one day visit a program you hold dear.
-Jeff Kramer
WWU Class of '85
Posted Thu, Jan 15, 10:17 p.m. Inappropriate
Jeff-
Well put!
Posted Fri, Jan 16, 8:14 a.m. Inappropriate
Where's Floyd? Cat got your keyboard?