Grace Crunican, the effective but controversial head of Seattle's Department of Transportation, is a finalist for becoming county administrator of Clackamas County in the Portland area. Sources expect her to get the job, returning to the state whence she was plucked by Mayor Nickels for the Seattle hot seat. Regardless, Mayor-elect McGinn has been quoted as saying he would replace Crunican.
While a lot of attention has been focused on McGinn's first round of appointments of twin deputy mayors and chief of staff, where he went light on City Hall experience and heavy on political outreach, it may be that his most important appointments are three others: Police chief (where the search process is just getting under way), transportation (Seattle's hottest topic), and the head of the department of finance (Dwight Dively's stronghold). Were the enormously experienced Dively not to be retained or choose to go elsewhere, that would be a huge signal to the bureaucracy of unsettling change.
Crunican gets strong points for her more-than-autos approach to transportation. She worked effectively with state transportation experts on crafting a systems-wide approach to downtown traffic. She's tougher than the usual passive-aggressive Seattle style. More than anyone inside government, she worked hard to make the case for the surface-only solution for the Viaduct, ultimately overruled by Gov. Gregoire and the tunnel coalition. Cary Moon, who led the effort for the no-tunnel, no-Viaduct solution, tells Publicola that McGinn should keep Crunican. She didn't score many points in her defensive reaction to the criticism of SDOT over the snowstorm. Still, it may be hard to find someone better for the highly exposed position.
McGinn's decision to spend the first month of his transition out on the campaign trail — gathering largely predictable opinions at town halls and charging up his troops for later use in supporting his policies — had some serious tradeoffs inside city hall. There's been little contact with department leaders, leaving them and their subordinates nervous about future directions. It also implies that the new mayor is not exactly on their side, available to help them in a tough time of cuts and poor morale. Nickels has been very much an "inside" mayor; McGinn looks most comfortable being an "outside" mayor, with deputy mayors on the same wave-length.
By vivid contrast, new county executive Dow Constantine quickly installed experienced top staff and sent powerful signals of reform and professionalism.
Like what you just read? Support high quality local journalism by becoming a member of Crosscut.com today!

Print
Email






Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feeds
Comments:
Posted Fri, Dec 4, 8:55 a.m. Inappropriate
Crunican is the very embodiment of the phrase "what does it take to get fired around here?" and McGinn would be a fool to retain her.
In regard to the comparison with Dow Constantine, I did not vote for McGinn, but the negative comparison is way off base - Constantine had to take office immediately, and McGinn does not do so until January. Kind of a difference there, really.
Posted Fri, Dec 4, 9:52 a.m. Inappropriate
Grace has done more for SDOT than any of the previous directors. Her departure would be a major loss for Seattle.
Posted Fri, Dec 4, 11:55 a.m. Inappropriate
Crunican should be measured by her performance which I consider poor. She may talk the talk, but she does not walk it.
I met with Cary Moon a year or so after the Nisqually quake to explain my analysis of the surface/transit option for Alaskan Way - possible only if the land-use element of the equation isn't neglected. Ballard and West Seattle economies must diversify to reduce need for cross-county travel and thus traffic on an Alaskan Way boulevard sans SR-99. Fixed route rapid transit is a critical element affecting this land-use equation.
The Alaskan Way surface/transit design has many severe faults which Crunican must answer for, the most obvious faults I believe Crunican dishonestly used to win support from people like Cary Moon.
First, the Wide Plaza and the streetcar line route through the middle of it were plainly bogus. The streetcar line there is unsafe and operationally difficult. Once Crunican was called out on the idea, she dropped replacing the popular streetcar line entirely. The Wide Plaza is bound to become makeshift and probably permanent parking lot. What a fine trick to play on delusional environmentalists Crunican must've thought in private.
Then there's the painted bicycle lanes in traffic, a cruel step down from the existing bike pathway. There's the 4-lane Alaskan Way design itself which supposedly will ably handle 40,000-70,000 vehicles daily running 15-20 stoplights. I don't think so. Few people think so. Crunican must know better.
Then, there's the Mercer West plan - a travesty that converts Mercer into a freight corridor between Elliott and I-5, as if Mercer Street isn't already overloaded through SLU, and as if a hill-climb through a high-density neighborhood to reach the Deep-bore tunnel portal on Aurora is a fine replacement for the more direct and level access to SR-99 at Western/Elliott.
Clackamas County in Oregon is largely republican. Crunican would probably like living there among her own kind of ruthless elitists awaiting doomsday, but she should not work in a planning department anywhere ever again. Her work in the field is patently devious.
Posted Fri, Dec 4, 1:38 p.m. Inappropriate
Grace is an outstanding person by any measure. She'll be a good fit in Oregon.
SDOT is a great organization, mostly. But it, and Grace, are probably the biggest single reason why we have a new Mayor. That too long running snow drama was entirely preventable.
Let's hope the new Mayor focuses on hiring a replacement with credentials in the basics of keeping things moving safely.
McGinn seems plenty capable of promoting progressive transportation policies without an assist from the SDOT leader. And if I were him, I hold off on focusing too much attention on trying to change the ways we move around, until he can demonstrate credibility with the basics.
Posted Fri, Dec 4, 2:03 p.m. Inappropriate
Grace Crunican came to Seattle after 'suddenly' leaving her position as ODOT chief. The reason she resigned was most likely her contemptable disregard for pedestrian and bicylist infrastructure in Portland's Ross Island Bridge surface rebuild project. Pedestrian advocates pled for widening the single 5' sidewalk on the bridge's north side. "No way" said Crunican. Even though an 18" catwalk on the south side was removed, those inches were added to the bridges four lanes which increased average traffic speeds. There's no room for a bike lane on this bridge, so the heavy traffic which averages 45+mph is mere inches from pedestrians. To top it off, Grace decided the new steel guard rail would NOT be installed between the traffic lanes and the sidewalk as is the case with other Portland bridges crossing the Willamette. "Forget it" said Crunican and elected to protect motorists from crashing into the ornate concrete ballistrade, but not pedestrians in the way. BTW, the new steel guard rail obliterated the 'ornate' part of the ballistrade. Nice. Now, Grace is 'suddenly' leaving Seattle leaving behind a worse record than she left in Oregon.
Posted Fri, Dec 4, 3:59 p.m. Inappropriate
Good riddance! She will be a perfect fit for Clackamas County, which isn't exactly a haven for cyclists or environmentalists.
Posted Sat, Dec 5, 11:52 a.m. Inappropriate
I don't see evidence of a true more-than-autos approach at SDOT. In what substantial ways is Seattle more walkable than before the Nickles-Crunican era? I see a token investment in sidewalks, bicycle lanes that may be worse than nothing at all, an unwillingness to inconvenience any motorist for the benefit of pedestrians, and a PR-oriented Pedestrian Master Plan without aggressive goals and measurable outcomes, much less innovative thinking. There are many ways to make Seattle more walkable that require no substantial investment, but do require political will. Let's remind the candidates that they pledged to support "war on cars" at the Washington Bus 'Survivor' candidate forum. Let's make a more walkable Seattle the first test of the our new political leadership. More at www.lightandair.wordpress.com.