Top of the News

Chosen and ranked by Crosscut editors. Click date for previous days.

Mouse over headline for description.

more top of the news

Advertisement

Advertisement

Mossback »

May 8, 2007 12:00 AM | last updated May 7, 2007 10:20 PM
An RFID tag in a passport.

An RFID chip embedded in the page of a passport. (IndyMedia.org)

Advertisement
Advertisement

For just $20, you can be Big Brother, too!

And so can hackers, stalkers, private marketers, and terrorists! All of these potential predators may target radio chip identification technology, the kind used to charge road tolls, track your shopping habits, or validate your driver's license.

By Knute Berger

Washington state, like the rest of the nation, is barreling along full-speed into the world of radio frequency identity (RFID) chips, which will soon be used in the new state "enhanced" driver's licenses and are being used to collect tolls on the new Tacoma Narrows Bridge. They are, in fact, being used in many products, from new U.S. passports to highway E-Z Passes to medical ID cards to store price tags.

But concerns are being raised about the security of the technology and whether it could enable invasions of privacy by government, hackers, private companies, terrorists, stalkers, and pranksters.

Some recent, sobering articles suggest that Washington policy-makers should take these concerns very seriously, and consumers should be wary until security and privacy concerns are addressed. The rush to create radio-chipped driver's licenses — approved by the Legislature and signed into law by Gov. Chris Gregoire this year as part of a federal pilot project — is of particular concern.

An article in Wired gives an overview of the rapid expansion of RFID:

RFID chips are everywhere — companies and labs use them as access keys, Prius owners use them to start their cars, and retail giants like Wal-Mart have deployed them as inventory tracking devices. Drug manufacturers like Pfizer rely on chips to track pharmaceuticals. The tags are also about to get a lot more personal: Next-gen U.S. passports and credit cards will contain RFIDs, and the medical industry is exploring the use of implantable chips to manage patients. According to the RFID market analysis firm IDTechEx, the push for digital inventory tracking and personal ID systems will expand the current annual market for RFIDs from $2.7 billion to as much as $26 billion by 2016.

The problem is that the risks are considerable. According to eWeek.com:

As if RFID chips in driver's licenses and passports weren't scary enough already, London's Royal Academy of Engineering is suggesting that someday a terrorist will be able to read personal details from a distance and, given the right antennas and amplification, set a bomb to go off when a particular person gets within range.

It's already widely acknowledged that unencrypted data stored on an RFID chip in a passport can be read covertly by anybody with a pass-by reader.

As the [American Civil Liberties Union] pointed out at Black Hat earlier in March, you can buy parts on the Internet to make a reader for as little as $20.

Wired offers a look at the ease with which RFID technology is hackable. Not only can data be read, stolen, and manipulated, but cookies can also be placed on the chips to allow private parties to track you. Wired follows several people who show just how easy it all is.

Aside from pranks, vandalism, and thievery, Grunwald has recently discovered another use for RFID chips: espionage. He programmed RFDump with the ability to place cookies on RFID tags the same way Web sites put cookies on browsers to track returning customers. With this, a stalker could, say, place a cookie on his target's E-Z Pass, then return to it a few days later to see which toll plazas the car had crossed (and when). Private citizens and the government could likewise place cookies on library books to monitor who's checking them out.

With current proposals to expand road tolls throughout the Seattle area in the name of congestion pricing — meaning every vehicle would be carrying on trackable RFID transponder — that revelation is particularly scary.

If Washington officials and policy-makers aren't scared yet, perhaps they should talk to their colleagues in California. There, a bill is working its way through the Legislature to limit the use of RFID. Kim Zetter of Wired reports:

The bill, which California lawmakers believe is the first of its kind in the nation, would prohibit the use of radio-frequency identification, or RFID, chips in state identity documents such as student badges, driver's licenses, medical cards and state employee cards.

The bill does make some exceptions for devices used to collect bridge and road tolls and tracking prison or mental health facility inmates, for example. But it would limit abuses by the government or unauthorized hackers:

Concerns about RFID center around surreptitious scanning and tracking, since data on the chips can be picked up by either an authorized or an unauthorized reader without the knowledge of the person carrying the chip.

For example, a student participating in a protest on a state university campus could be scanned by a campus policeman carrying a reader to track his political activities. Or, depending on the kind of data stored on the card, someone could read the data on a chip in order to clone it and create false documents.

One of the incidents that sparked concern in California involved real students. Not hypothetical college protesters, but elementary school kids being used as RFID guinea pigs:

In January, Brittan Elementary School in Sutter, Calif., began requiring students to wear photo ID cards embedded with an RFID chip containing a 15-digit number assigned to each student to track attendance.

The school cut a deal with a local maker of the technology to test the tracking system and receive a percentage of profits if the company succeeded in selling the system to other school districts. But after a group of outraged parents protested the plan, the school dropped it.

The federal government is also looking at RFID standards and pitfalls. According to eWeek.com, the "National Institute of Standards and Technology, a nonregulatory agency of the U.S. Department of Commerce, has published its guidelines for deploying radio-frequency identification."

The agency also lays out concerns that are specific to the growth in use of the technology. The more widespread RFID is, the greater the potential for privacy abuses:

As people possess more tagged items and networked RFID readers become ever more prevalent, organizations may have the ability to combine and correlate data across applications to infer personal identity and location, and build personal profiles in ways that increase the privacy risk," wrote the report's author.

In other words, RFID dramatically expands our capability to create and mine databases of personal information, travel records, shopping patterns, health records, and more.

RFID is not the only problem. A report in USA Today on May 3 indicates that Homeland Security is studying the feasibility of installing all cell phones with a radiation, biological, and chemical detector tied to a national GPS system that would allow each phone to be tracked and located.

And it isn't only ordinary citizens who are concerned about being tracked: even U.S. Defense Deartment contractors are getting jumpy, as with the recent Canadian coin surviellance scare.

In short, we have not only Big Brother to worry about but potentially millions of his Little Brothers, as well.

  • Knute Berger is Mossback, Crosscut's chief Northwest native. He also writes the monthly Gray Matters column for Seattle magazine and is a weekly Friday guest on Weekday on KUOW-FM (94.9). You can e-mail him at mossback@crosscut.com.
Comments
well, it's possible to disable cookies on your computer, by choice
Report a violationPosted by: mikerolm on May 8, 2007 7:28 AM
so one disabling cookie placed in the monkey tag might do the trick. i meself am not all that troubled by being targeted by grrists of mass distraction via the occasional chimp; and my guess is that mr. berger only brings up this possibilty to frighten the reader into contemplating the possibility of the biggest terrorist of them all knowing where you are at all times. each of us poodles at the beck and call of our master. the dick cheney in the sky!
i can see my future...
Report a violationPosted by: cwesley on May 8, 2007 8:20 AM
I can see my future... and it includes tinfoil-lined wallets. problem solved!
RFID Fears
Report a violationPosted by: Matt on May 8, 2007 8:49 AM
I think the RFID in a drivers license is a valid fear, for all of the reasons stated. The EZPass fear is a bit less founded - all we really have to do is require them to be encrypted.

But the fear of RFID chips in library books is just silly. "Private citizens and the government could likewise place cookies on library books to monitor who's checking them out." I'm less concerned about private citizens hacking into my library records as I am of the government monitoring/screening me. But that's already happening thanks to the Patriot Act - no standing around with an RFID reader necessary. From the Seattle Public Library website:

"Under provisions of the act, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and law enforcement officials may seek court orders for Library records for investigations relevant to national security or terrorism. Libraries or librarians served with these search warrants may not disclose, under penalty of law, the existence of the warrants or the fact that records were produced as a result of the warrants. Patrons cannot be told their records were given to law enforcement agencies or that they were the subjects of FBI investigations. "

The SPL website also mentions that this clause sunsets in 2005, but clearly hasn't been updated as the Patriot act was reauthorized in 2006.
Pandora's Box Has Been Open for a Long Time
Report a violationPosted by: Stuka on May 8, 2007 12:23 PM
Editor's Pick The box has been opened. The information is out there, the technology is out there, the bad guys are out there, the social engineers are out there, the corporations are out there, the cops are out there, the terrorist are out there, the spammers are out there, the opportunity for good is out there, the opportunity for bad is out there.

Let's face the challenge and not bury our heads in the sand. Remember cash before credit cards? Remember the computer before the internet? Remember your brain before you were born? (okay, maybe hard too do...) The world is always becoming more and more connected. RFID and all Big Brotherish technologies will present problems and challenges to privacy and individual freedom. But we can't ignore them. We must embrace them and put them to positive use, while putting in robust safeguards against negative uses. Banks and corporations shouldn't be the only people using technology to make a better world. Government and the public have the most to gain, because government has historically been such a technological laggard, and the public interest has been co-opted through government's relative incompetence in dealing with corporations and special interests.

I make these remarks in the context of value-pricing of our transportation infrastructure through transponders and RFID technology. If government cannot even figure out how to scan automobiles to properly price the value in its infrastructure investments, then it should just fold up its tent and go home. The institutional incompetence and disarray is frightful. Bringing a market orientation to government will help blast out the bureaucratic deadwood that is jamming the river of public good that should be flowing throughout our public institutions. Government should move into this technological century and start using the bleeding edge billing technology found in cell phone bills and Visa statements. Do you think the private sector has just maybe thought about privacy issues before?

Okay, I'm being harsh. Government isn't easy. The legal and political constraints complex and messy. Government has plenty of smart people, but generally they're organized to succeed at bureaucracy and to fail at innovation, efficiency, and effectiveness. Technology often presents opportunities to leapfrog problems of the past by obsoleting old paradigms. Using RFID technology is one of those chances. All the good and smart people in government should love it. (As for the bad and dumb, I'm not sure what we should do...)
WSDOT - Good To Go!
Report a violationPosted by: WSDOT Good To Go! on May 9, 2007 5:25 PM
Good To Go! is the electronic toll collection system that will be used in Washington for future toll projects. Good To Go! works on a passive system that activates only in the presence of the specific technology installed at the toll location; it does not broadcast a signal at all times. Customers account information is not stored on the transponder chip. Instead, customer account information is encrypted on the customer service database and protected on servers that are behind the firewall. The only way to link the toll transaction captured by the transponder at the toll location to the specific customer account is via the specialized readers installed at the toll plaza. Without the readers, the transponders are useless. Further, the transponders do not store previous transactions so travel patterns cannot be determined from the transponder itself.
Good To Go! customer service centers are now open so drivers who use the Tacoma Narrows Bridge can establish their accounts now and be prepared for the new bridge that will open this summer. Good To Go! will be used on the future SR 167 HOT lanes in 2008. More information is available at www.wsdot.wa.gov/goodtogo.
Growth Industry on the horizon
Report a violationPosted by: Cameron on May 11, 2007 8:17 AM
I wonder how long it will take some enterprising group of young folks to develop an EZ pass that will be accepted by the transponder readers at the toll booths but send garbage or a worm into the system to crash it or avoid being billed. Kids will be kids after all.
Buy
Report a violationPosted by: compiknews on May 30, 2008 9:42 AM
Viagra ed treatment
Report a violationPosted by: octavia on Sep 1, 2008 12:06 AM
Viagra is prescribed to treat erectile dysfunction (ED).If you take any medicines that have nitrates
in them (like nitroglycerin for chest pain)—every day or even once in a while—you should NOT take VIAGRA.
Discuss your general health status with your doctor to ensure that you are healthy enough to engage in sexual activity. If you experience chest pain, nausea, or any other discomforts during sex, seek immediate medical help.
Although erections lasting for more than 4 hours may occur rarely with all ED treatments in this drug class, to avoid long-term injuries, it is important to seek immediate medical help. Make a real step and Order Viagra Online
If you are older than age 65, or have serious liver or kidney problems, your doctor may start you at the lowest dose (25 mg) of VIAGRA. If you are taking protease inhibitors, such as for the treatment of HIV, your doctor may recommend a 25-mg dose and may limit you to a maximum single dose of 25 mg of VIAGRA in a 48-hour period.Save money now and Buy Viagra Online
Advertisement
Advertisement

Sign up for Crosscut's free weekday newsletter e-mail.
About Crosscut
Advertising Info
Crosscut's list of RSS feeds.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Crosscut »
Crosscut Seattle is an online newspaper for the Pacific Northwest, including Washington, Oregon, Idaho, and British Columbia. It's a guide to local and regional news, a place to report and discuss news, and a platform for new tools to convey news.

• More about Crosscut

Contact Crosscut

Tools

Sign up for Crosscut's daily newsletter
About Crosscut
Advertising Info
Crosscut's list of RSS feeds.
Advertisement