A rare and stunning performance of musical poetry

Seattle Chamber Players and Pacific Musicworks put on a striking version of 'Songs of Wars I Have Seen'
Crosscut archive image.

Songs of Wars I Have Seen

Seattle Chamber Players and Pacific Musicworks put on a striking version of 'Songs of Wars I Have Seen'

Heiner Goebbels is a well-known European avant-garde composer whose works have rarely been performed in the U.S. This is too bad, if 'ꀜSong of Wars I Have Seen,'ꀝ a stunning hour-long chamber work, is representative. The Seattle Chamber Players heard a Goebbels'ꀙ piece at a Warsaw festival, and immediately determined to present one in Seattle. This they did, March 4-6, with the early music ensemble Pacific Musicworks, under the auspices of On the Boards.

'ꀜSongs of Wars I Have Seen'ꀝ is based on texts of Gertrude Stein (written in 1943, published in 1945). Stein'ꀙs inherently musical poetry is made up of sounds and rhythms as much as it is syntax and semantics. The poems document women'ꀙs experience of war, sitting at home, rather than out on the battlefield. Because of rationing, the women use honey instead of sugar; they listen to BBC and Voice of America on the radio; they hear the threatening sound of airplanes overhead. They read Shakespeare — Richard III and Macbeth — and ponder the historical and timeless quality of war.

It was apparently Stein'ꀙs references to Shakespeare that inspired Goebbels to use fragments of Matthew Locke'ꀙs music for The Tempest (1674) as a recurring part of his composition. And of course, the Locke should be played on period instruments, with the mellow sounds of Baroque strings.

Goebbels'ꀙ piece is the only one I'ꀙve ever heard that successfully combines the timbres of period instruments tuned at A-415 (Baroque pitch) with 'ꀜmodern'ꀝ orchestral instruments tuned at A-440. In addition, there are electronic sounds, controlled both by a keyboard/computer sampler onstage and by CD playback from the sound booth. While this is a piece of 'ꀜchamber music,'ꀝ it does require a conductor, and the Estonian Anu Tali, who had conducted the piece several times previously, did a fine job of coordinating everything.

The most striking thing about the stage set-up is the gender separation. The women performers (Baroque strings, harp, and some woodwinds) sit at the front of the stage in a sort of 'ꀜliving room,'ꀝ with the soft lighting of floor lamps and table lamps of varied sizes, shapes, and colors. The male instrumentalists (brass, percussion, keyboard, lute, and some woodwinds) sit at the back of the stage, with harsh theatrical lighting and a bare light bulb hanging down overhead. The women serve as the narrators/storytellers, reading the poetry individually and as a group chorus, in addition to their instrumental duties. I particularly enjoyed violist Laurel Wells'ꀙ rapid-fire delivery and the partly-sung narration of bass player Moriah Neils.

I happened to talk with Paul Taub, the flutist, after the performance. He said that the flute part could be played by a male or female (who would be seated in different parts of the stage, depending on gender). Also, the flute part could be played on a wooden Baroque flute pitched at A-415 or on a modern silver flute at A-440. So there'ꀙs a certain amount of flexibility in the orchestration and in players'ꀙ gender.

The 'ꀜsong'ꀝ portions of the piece (Stein poems of different moods) are occasionally separated by instrumental interludes, and the piece ends with a striking trumpet postlude (played beautifully here by Tony DiLorenzo) — strange, microtonal riffs over the eerie harmonics of Tibetan prayer bowls, 'ꀜstirred'ꀝ by most of the other performers on stage. This is trumpet not as martial fanfare instrument, but as mournful graveyard soloist. 'ꀜSongs of Wars'ꀝ ends with prayers for the dead, not with victorious hymns.

The companion piece on the first half of the program was Monteverdi'ꀙs "Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda," first performed in 1624, and here performed by Pacific Musicworks. It is an experiment in the early development of opera, based on a section of Tasso'ꀙs epic "Gerusalemme liberata," and its themes (like the Goebbels) are war and gender.

A narrator — tenor Ross Hauck, who delivered a very compelling performance — tells the story of two knights, a Christian and a Saracen who meet in battle and fight valiantly until the fatal wounding of the Saracen. When the Christian knight removes the helmet of the warrior, he discovers that it is none other than the Saracen maiden with whom he had earlier fallen in love. He hurriedly baptizes her, sending her soul to heaven at the last.

The swordplay and actions of the combat are directly mirrored in the music, with 'ꀜbattle effects'ꀝ in the strings and occasional series of short repeated notes by the narrator, a newly created 'ꀜstile concitato'ꀝ to express anger and violence. Unfortunately, it is difficult for a contemporary audience to view someone trotting around on stage, pretending to be on a horse, without having visions of Spamalot pop to mind, and the brightly colored costumes (undoubtedly modeled on 17th-century drawings) looked clownish. What to do when such 'ꀜauthenticity'ꀝ elicits giggles? Director Theodore Deacon'ꀙs solution, in an Early Music Guild performance a few years back, was to use a motorcycle and contemporary dress (not to everyone'ꀙs taste). One could ham it up and play it entirely for laughs, but that would not be in keeping with the (serious) spirit of the work. Perhaps a concert performance, with minimal staging, is the best solution.


Please support independent local news for all.

We rely on donations from readers like you to sustain Crosscut's in-depth reporting on issues critical to the PNW.


About the Authors & Contributors