Humor: Why should I 'have a good one'?

People wishing me such a thing leave me befuddled, and reaching for just the right withering reply.
Crosscut archive image.

Have a nice day I can get. But "have a good one"?

People wishing me such a thing leave me befuddled, and reaching for just the right withering reply.

Retail clerks, recovering accountants, and others who hold me in low esteem have begun to wish me "a good one." They say, 'ꀜHave a good one'ꀝ instead of 'ꀜHave a good day.'ꀝ

Perhaps they ceased wishing me a 'ꀜgood day'ꀝ to avoid my devastating rejoinders:

  • Great idea. Why didn'ꀙt I think of it first?
  • I'ꀙve already had mine this month.
  • Not today, but Friday might work.
  • Thanks, but I'ꀙm married.
  • I have other plans.
  • I am befuddled by 'ꀜhave a good one.'ꀝ Exactly what are they suggesting: A good day? A good quadruple bypass? A good soup and salad lunch? A good religious epiphany? A good tea party? A good bowel movement? A good Zen koan? The possibilities are endless.

    I could reply politely with, 'ꀜHave a good one yourself.'ꀝ But what if the recovering accountant meant, 'ꀜHave a good attack of shingles?'ꀝ I would not wish shingles on anyone other than a Yankee fan.

    I am currently testing five responses to 'ꀜhave a good one'ꀝ:

    • The probing: 'ꀜOne What?'ꀝ
    • The confrontational: 'ꀜAnd then what?'ꀝ
    • The non-committal: 'ꀜI will consider it.'ꀝ
    • The avaricious: 'ꀜWhat not a good two, or even a good eight?'ꀝ
    • The retributive: 'ꀜThe same to you if you'ꀙre a Yankee fan.'ꀝ

    Thus far, the above rejoinders have elicited remarkably similar responses — 'ꀜasshole,'ꀝ 'ꀜjerk,'ꀝ and 'ꀜI discern that you are not a native Seattleite.'ꀝ

    Results of my research will be published in Tenure: The Journal of Academic Academics.

      

Please support independent local news for all.

We rely on donations from readers like you to sustain Crosscut's in-depth reporting on issues critical to the PNW.

Donate

About the Authors & Contributors