One Dish: Succulent oxtails at Black Bottle

The Belltown bar's latest menu addition is a destination on its own: seasoned, seared and braised, then served with a malbec demiglace.

Crosscut archive image.

Henry Moore's "Vertebrae," with Seattle's Rem Koolhaas-designed library in the background.

The Belltown bar's latest menu addition is a destination on its own: seasoned, seared and braised, then served with a malbec demiglace.

Black Bottle, the gastro-tavern at First Avenue and Vine Street in Belltown, has been a hit since the day it opened, five and a half years ago. The owners (Chris Linker, Judy Boardman and Brian Durbin) added a second dining room, they added space for private events, they added a buck or two to the price of their menu items (but kept the food studioiusly unfussy).

And soon they're going to open a second Black Bottle on the Eastside, just down the street from Bellevue Square. 

But that's not the focus of this item, which is to sing the praises of a modest, $11 dish of braised oxtail and malbec demiglace. Durbin, Black Bottle's chef, had to recalibrate the ovens to ensure the proper seven-hour cooking of the dish; he won't put anything on the menu until it's just right.

Notable hits: grilled lamb with hummus; pork belly with kimchee; and a dish called "broccoli blasted." Although, truth be told, the kitchen isn't foolproof. Early on, Matthew Amster-Burton, writing in The Seattle Times, hated the broccoli, which was served charred to a crisp. And last week (one night when Durbin wasn't in the kitchen), the party seated next to me at the bar was served a brocoli that tasted as if it had been blasted with bitter garlic.

The oxtail dish, which landed on the menu in December, starts with the raw material: fresh oxtails from MacDonald Meat in South Seattle, the same folks who deliver burger patties to Dick's. The oxtail is just that, 7- to 10-pound chunks of tail (minus the very tip) that the kitchen crew breaks down, severing bone by bone and trimming off any remaining fat. The pieces are seasoned, seared over high heat, then braised. Meanwhile, they create the base for the demiglace of malbec (the Bordeaux variety that's taken off in Argentina and Washington), soy sauce, brown sugar, and aromatic herbs. 

When the time comes, one of the line cooks — it was Ezra Schwepker on a recent weeknight — drops two or three pieces of meat into a pan, adds a scoop of the jellied glaze, and sets the saute pan over high heat for several minutes so the meat can absorb heat and moisture through the sauce. From time to time, he turns the tails so they're well-coated. When all is right, he hands the pan off to a kitchen assistant, Stacy Ellison, who plates the dish, strains what's left of the reduced sauce through a sieve, adds a garnish of tarragon and rosemary, and sends the oxtails out.

Speak to the dish harshly and the meat will fall off the bone. It is exquisitely tender and intensely flavorful, redolent of beefiness. You can't stop yourself; you pick up the bones, nibble the cartilage, and suck down every last skerrick of meat. What's left on your plate resembles the "Vertebrae" sculpture by Henry Moore at Safeco Plaza on Fourth Avenue. 

If you go: Black Bottle, 2600 First Ave., Seattle, 206-441-1500. Black Bottle Postern is scheduled to open at the Avalon Towers, 10349 N.E. 10th St., Bellevue, in mid-February.


Please support independent local news for all.

We rely on donations from readers like you to sustain Crosscut's in-depth reporting on issues critical to the PNW.


About the Authors & Contributors

Ronald Holden

Ronald Holden

Ronald Holden is a regular Crosscut contributor. His new book, published this month, is titled “HOME GROWN Seattle: 101 True Tales of Local Food & Drink." (Belltown Media. $17.95).