Senate ties cuts to I-1351 costs to budget action

Crosscut archive image.

A teacher with her students

Setting the stage for likely-lengthy negotiations over the state budget, the Washington Senate passed a bill Monday that would effectively send Initiative 1351 back to voters this November.

Passed in late 2014, I-1351 calls for dramatically reduced teacher-student ratios in Grades K-12. It would also add roughly $2 billion in education expenses in 2015-2017. Gov. Jay Inslee and both parties in Legislature have cringed at that obligation, because no revenue source has been identified to raise the money.

The Democratic-controlled House and the Republican-controlled Senate's budget proposals both look to tie meeting I-1351's obligations for Grades K-3 with their efforts to comply with a 2012 Washington Supreme Court ruling that requires improvements in teacher-student ratios in those grades. Both sides, however, want to essentially put off I-1351's obligations for Grades 4-12 in 2015-2017, because no money is available.

The House's 2015-2017 proposal does not address I-1351 further. The just-passed Senate bill includes a referendum clause that amounts to sending I-1351 back to the voters in November to confirm they want the additional $2 billion per biennium obligation.

Speaking of I-1351, Sen. John Braun, R-Centralia, said, "It's pretty clear at this point that it is not affordable." I-1351 "was built on false promises and sold on false advertising," contended Sen. Mike Baumgartner, R-Spokane.

While some minority Democrats also believe that I-1351 is not affordable, all but one voted against the Republican bill to send the measure back to the voters.

Sen. James Hargrove, D-Hoquiam, argued that if voters approve the measure again, the Legislature will be hit with a full $2 billion obligation that might have to be dealt with immediately. Sen. Cyrus Habib, D-Kirkland, contended that last year's voters were aware of the price tag. "The people very well understood what small class sizes mean," he said.

The Senate voted 27-22 to send the bill to the House. Sen. Mark Mullet, D-Issaquah, crossed the aisle to vote with the Republicans.

Meanwhile, the Senate voted 26-23 along caucus lines to approve a $38 billion operating budget proposal for the 2015-2017 biennium that features a significant drop in state university tuitions and no new taxes. The state’s current 2013-2015 budget is about $34 billion. The Senate Republicans’ $38 billion has $1.3 billion earmarked for the court-ordered work in Grades K-3. The Senate budget raises $40 million by letting 15 tax breaks expire. The Republicans plan to pay for the K-3 obligations without new revenue sources.

Last Thursday, the House, by a 51-47 party line vote, passed a $38.8 billion budget proposal with $1.4 billion earmarked for improvements in Grades K-3 ordered by the Washington Supreme Court. The House budget envisions financing some of its costs through a new capital gains tax; a hike in the business-and-occupation tax paid by services firms; and closing seven tax breaks.

Senate Democrats criticized the GOP budget for trimming already-negotiated salary increases for state employees; for taking money from non-operating funds to pay for operating fund work; and for trimming at least $150 million needed for expected growth in social services obligations.

Sen. Doug Ericksen, R-Ferndale, praised the Senate budget proposal. "The budget is balanced without job-killing manufacturing tax increases. ... Low tuition is the best financial aid you can have," Ericksen said.

All this sets up behind-the-scenes negotiations between the House Democrats and Senate Republicans that are expected to last weeks, if not months.


Please support independent local news for all.

We rely on donations from readers like you to sustain Crosscut's in-depth reporting on issues critical to the PNW.


About the Authors & Contributors

John Stang

John Stang

John Stang is a freelance writer who often covers state government and the environment. He can be reached on email at and on Twitter at @johnstang_8